Kendler K S, Ohlsson H, Morris N A, Sundquist J, Sundquist K
Virginia Institute for Psychiatric and Behavioral Genetics, Virginia Commonwealth University,Richmond,VA,USA.
Center for Primary Health Care Research, Lund University,Malmö,Sweden.
Psychol Med. 2015 Apr;45(5):1093-102. doi: 10.1017/S0033291714002268. Epub 2014 Sep 17.
While children of parents with criminal behavior (CB) are at increased risk for CB, we have limited knowledge about the causes of this cross-generational transmission.
We examined intergenerational continuity in CB in the Swedish population ascertained from the national conviction registers in three family types: intact (n = 21 11 074), 'not-lived-with' (n = 16 53 15 where biological parents never lived with their offspring) and 'step' (n = 1 24 800 offspring) which reflected, respectively, the effects of genes + rearing, genes only and rearing only. We also examined three criminal conviction subtypes: violent CB (VCB), property CB (PCB) and white-collar CB (WCCB).
Combined across mothers and fathers, the hazard ratio (HR) for CB in offspring given parental CB was 1.95 in intact, 1.56 in 'not-lived-with' and 1.28 in stepfamilies. In all three family types, all forms of CB in parents (VCB, PCB and WCCB) significantly predicted risk for all forms of CB in offspring. However, VCB in offspring was most strongly predicted by VCB in parents in intact, not-lived-with and stepfamilies. In intact families only, some specific parent-offspring transmission was also seen for WCCB.
Both genetic and environmental factors contribute substantially to parent-offspring resemblance for CB. With respect to criminal subtypes, much of parent-offspring transmission appears to be non-specific. However, specific genetic and environmental risk factors for VCB are transmitted across generations. A limitation of these analyses is that CB was assessed only via official criminal convictions.
父母有犯罪行为(CB)的子女出现CB的风险增加,但我们对这种代际传递的原因了解有限。
我们研究了瑞典人群中CB的代际连续性,数据来自国家定罪登记册,涉及三种家庭类型:完整家庭(n = 2111074)、“未共同生活”家庭(n = 165315,亲生父母从未与子女共同生活)和“继”家庭(n = 124800名子女),分别反映了基因+养育、仅基因和仅养育的影响。我们还研究了三种刑事定罪亚型:暴力犯罪行为(VCB)、财产犯罪行为(PCB)和白领犯罪行为(WCCB)。
综合父母双方来看,父母有CB时子女出现CB的风险比(HR)在完整家庭中为1.95,在“未共同生活”家庭中为1.56,在继家庭中为1.28。在所有三种家庭类型中,父母的所有形式的CB(VCB、PCB和WCCB)都显著预测了子女所有形式CB的风险。然而,在完整家庭、“未共同生活”家庭和继家庭中,子女的VCB最强烈地由父母的VCB预测。仅在完整家庭中,WCCB也存在一些特定的亲子传递情况。
遗传和环境因素都对CB亲子相似性有很大贡献。就犯罪亚型而言,许多亲子传递似乎是非特异性的。然而,VCB的特定遗传和环境风险因素会代代相传。这些分析的一个局限性是,CB仅通过官方刑事定罪来评估。