Wang Hongtian, Zhang Jing, You Shaohua, Ao Yanyun, Bai Yin, Shi Huaiyin, Ji Lingchao, Jia Jingjie, Zhang Yue, Jia Hongxia
Department of Otorhinolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, the Chinese PLA General Hospital, Beijing 100853, China. Email:
Zhonghua Er Bi Yan Hou Tou Jing Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2014 Jun;49(6):501-5.
To explore a step-by-step exclusive diagnosis and analyze the clinical characters of non-allergic rhinitis (NAR).
Patients with symptoms (nasal itching, sneezing, rhinorrhea, nasal congestion) were selected to take four-step exclusive diagnosis for NAR and we tried to eliminate the false NAR and retain the true NAR. First step was to exclude the patients who were not suitable for skin prick test (SPT, such as during pregnancy, breastfeeding, asthma, oral antihistamine medication in 7 day, severe skin diseases). The second step was to exclude the patients with positive SPT and the third step was to exclude the patients with 1 level or above of specific sero-immunoglobulin E (sIgE). The fourth step was to exclude the patients with infection rhinitis, clear abnormal nasal structure, drug-induced rhinitis, nasal neoplasm. The remained patients were finally diagnosed as NAR and who were further differential diagnosed as vasomotor rhinitis (VMR) or non-allergic rhinitis with eosinophilia syndrome (NARES) according to the eosinophilia counts in nasal secretion and venous blood. The common characters of patients with NAR were analyzed and their symptoms and quality of life were evaluated by visual analogue scale (VAS) and rhino-conjunctivitis quality of life questionnaire (RQLQ) separately.
One thousand four hundred and thirty-seven patients were included after first step exclusion and 735 cases with negative SPT were remained after second step exclusion. Of 735 patients, 302 were tested in vitro for sIgE and 93 cases with 0 level of sIgE and total IgE were remained after third step exclusion. Sixty-two patients were finally diagnosed as NAR after fourth step exclusion. The NAR diagnosis rate was 51.15% (735/1 437) with negative SPT alone and the NAR diagnosis rate was 29.06% (93/302) with combination of negative SPT and sIgE. Of 62 patients with NAR, 47 patients (75.81%) were diagnosed as VMR and 15 cases (24.19%) as NARES. There were 23 males and 39 females in the 62 patients aged 11 - 77 years. The history was 11-47 months. The biggest numbers of patients with VMR or NARES were among 41-50 years. Their onset ages were among 21-30 years in both two groups. VAS scores of nasal congestion in VMR patients were the highest with significant difference among nasal symptoms (F = 3.958 0, P = 0.009 1). VAS scores of sneezing in NARES patients were the highest but without significant difference among nasal symptoms. There were no difference in seven domain scores of RQLQ and the total mean scores between VMR group and NARES group but the nasal symptoms got the highest scores with significant difference among the seven domains in each group (VMR group, F = 9.771 2, P = 0.000 0;NRAES group, F = 3.226 9, P = 0.006 2).
SPT combined with sIgE may exclude much more patients with AR. Females with NAR are much more than males. Patients with NAR aged 21-30 years. The characters of NAR are helpful to improve our knowledge about NAR. VAS and RQLQ may be a suitable tool in assessment of NAR.
探索一种逐步排除诊断法,并分析非变应性鼻炎(NAR)的临床特征。
选择有鼻痒、喷嚏、流涕、鼻塞症状的患者进行NAR的四步排除诊断,尽量排除假阳性NAR,保留真正的NAR。第一步排除不适合皮肤点刺试验(SPT)的患者(如妊娠、哺乳期、哮喘、7天内口服抗组胺药、严重皮肤病患者)。第二步排除SPT阳性患者,第三步排除特异性血清免疫球蛋白E(sIgE)1级及以上患者。第四步排除感染性鼻炎、明确的鼻腔结构异常、药物性鼻炎、鼻腔肿瘤患者。最终诊断为NAR的患者,根据鼻分泌物和静脉血中嗜酸性粒细胞计数进一步鉴别诊断为血管运动性鼻炎(VMR)或嗜酸粒细胞增多性非变应性鼻炎(NARES)。分析NAR患者的一般特征,并分别采用视觉模拟量表(VAS)和鼻结膜炎生活质量问卷(RQLQ)评估其症状和生活质量。
第一步排除后纳入1437例患者,第二步排除后剩余735例SPT阴性患者。735例患者中,302例进行了sIgE体外检测,第三步排除后剩余93例sIgE和总IgE均为0级的患者。第四步排除后最终诊断为NAR的患者62例。单纯SPT阴性时NAR诊断率为51.15%(735/1437),SPT阴性联合sIgE时NAR诊断率为29.06%(93/302)。62例NAR患者中,47例(75.81%)诊断为VMR,15例(24.19%)诊断为NARES。62例患者中男性23例,女性39例,年龄11~77岁,病程11~47个月。VMR和NARES患者人数最多的年龄段为41~50岁,两组患者的发病年龄均在21~30岁。VMR患者鼻塞的VAS评分最高,各鼻部症状间差异有统计学意义(F = 3.958 0,P = 0.009 1)。NARES患者喷嚏的VAS评分最高,但各鼻部症状间差异无统计学意义。VMR组和NARES组RQLQ的7个领域评分及总平均分无差异,但鼻部症状评分最高,每组7个领域间差异有统计学意义(VMR组,F =
9.771 2,P = 0.000 0;NARES组,F = 3.226 9,P = 0.006 2)。
SPT联合sIgE可排除更多变应性鼻炎患者。NAR女性多于男性。NAR患者发病年龄在21~30岁。NAR的特征有助于提高我们对NAR的认识。VAS和RQLQ可能是评估NAR的合适工具。