Stein Catherine H, Leith Jaclyn E, Osborn Lawrence A, Greenberg Sarah, Petrowski Catherine E, Jesse Samantha, Kraus Shane W, May Michael C
Department of Psychology, Bowling Green State University, Bowling Green, Ohio, 43403, USA,
Psychiatr Q. 2015 Mar;86(1):33-48. doi: 10.1007/s11126-014-9325-3.
This qualitative study examined changes in community mental health care as described by adults diagnosed with schizophrenia with long-term involvement in the mental health system to situate their experiences within the context of mental health reform movements in the United States. A sample of 14 adults with schizophrenia who had been consumers of mental health services from 12 to 40 years completed interviews about their hospital and outpatient experiences over time and factors that contributed most to their mental health. Overall, adults noted gradual changes in mental health care over time that included higher quality of care, more humane treatment, increased partnership with providers, shorter hospital stays, and better conditions in inpatient settings. Regardless of the mental health reform era in which they were hospitalized, participants described negative hospitalization experiences resulting in considerable personal distress, powerlessness, and trauma. Adults with less than 27 years involvement in the system reported relationships with friends and family as most important to their mental health, while adults with more than 27 years involvement reported mental health services and relationships with professionals as the most important factors in their mental health. The sample did not differ in self-reported use of services during their initial and most recent hospitalization experiences, but differences were found in participants' reported use of outpatient services over time. Findings underscore the importance of the lived experience of adults with schizophrenia in grounding current discourse on mental health care reform.
这项定性研究考察了长期参与心理健康系统的成年精神分裂症患者所描述的社区心理健康护理的变化情况,以便将他们的经历置于美国心理健康改革运动的背景之中。抽取了14名成年精神分裂症患者作为样本,他们作为心理健康服务的消费者已有12至40年,完成了关于他们随时间推移的住院和门诊经历以及对其心理健康贡献最大的因素的访谈。总体而言,成年患者指出,随着时间的推移,心理健康护理逐渐发生了变化,包括护理质量提高、治疗更加人性化、与医护人员的合作增加、住院时间缩短以及住院环境改善。无论他们住院处于哪个心理健康改革时代,参与者都描述了负面的住院经历,这些经历导致了相当大的个人痛苦、无力感和创伤。参与该系统不到27年的成年患者报告称,朋友和家人的关系对他们的心理健康最为重要,而参与超过27年的成年患者则报告称,心理健康服务以及与专业人员的关系是他们心理健康的最重要因素。该样本在首次和最近一次住院经历中自我报告的服务使用情况并无差异,但随着时间的推移,参与者报告的门诊服务使用情况存在差异。研究结果强调了成年精神分裂症患者的实际经历在为当前关于心理健康护理改革的讨论提供依据方面的重要性。