Chaibi Aleksander, Russell Michael Bjørn
Head and Neck Research Group, Research Centre, Akershus University Hospital, 1478 Lørenskog, Oslo, Norway.
J Headache Pain. 2014 Oct 2;15(1):67. doi: 10.1186/1129-2377-15-67.
This is to our knowledge the first systematic review regarding the efficacy of manual therapy randomized clinical trials (RCT) for primary chronic headaches. A comprehensive English literature search on CINHAL, Cochrane, Medline, Ovid and PubMed identified 6 RCTs all investigating chronic tension-type headache (CTTH). One study applied massage therapy and five studies applied physiotherapy. Four studies were considered to be of good methodological quality by the PEDro scale. All studies were pragmatic or used no treatment as a control group, and only two studies avoided co-intervention, which may lead to possible bias and makes interpretation of the results more difficult. The RCTs suggest that massage and physiotherapy are effective treatment options in the management of CTTH. One of the RCTs showed that physiotherapy reduced headache frequency and intensity statistical significant better than usual care by the general practitioner. The efficacy of physiotherapy at post-treatment and at 6 months follow-up equals the efficacy of tricyclic antidepressants. Effect size of physiotherapy was up to 0.62. Future manual therapy RCTs are requested addressing the efficacy in chronic migraine with and without medication overuse. Future RCTs on headache should adhere to the International Headache Society's guidelines for clinical trials, i.e., frequency as primary end-point, while duration and intensity should be secondary end-point, avoid co-intervention, includes sufficient sample size and follow-up period for at least 6 months.
据我们所知,这是关于手法治疗对原发性慢性头痛的随机临床试验(RCT)疗效的首次系统评价。在CINHAL、Cochrane、Medline、Ovid和PubMed上进行的全面英文文献检索,共识别出6项均针对慢性紧张型头痛(CTTH)的随机对照试验。其中1项研究采用了按摩疗法,5项研究采用了物理疗法。根据PEDro量表,4项研究被认为具有良好的方法学质量。所有研究均采用实用方法或使用无治疗作为对照组,只有2项研究避免了联合干预,这可能导致潜在偏差并使结果的解释更加困难。随机对照试验表明,按摩和物理疗法是治疗慢性紧张型头痛的有效选择。其中一项随机对照试验表明,物理疗法在降低头痛频率和强度方面比全科医生的常规治疗在统计学上有更显著的效果。物理疗法在治疗后及6个月随访时的疗效等同于三环类抗抑郁药的疗效。物理疗法的效应量高达0.62。未来需要开展手法治疗的随机对照试验,以探讨其对伴或不伴有药物过度使用的慢性偏头痛的疗效。未来关于头痛的随机对照试验应遵循国际头痛协会的临床试验指南,即以发作频率作为主要终点,而持续时间和强度应作为次要终点,避免联合干预,纳入足够的样本量并进行至少6个月的随访。