Brown Matt J N, Almeida Quincy J, Rahimi Fariborz
Sun Life Financial Movement Disorders Research and Rehabilitation Centre (MDRC), Wilfrid Laurier University, 75 University Avenue West, Waterloo, ON, N2L 3C5, Canada.
J Neurol. 2015 Jan;262(1):41-53. doi: 10.1007/s00415-014-7514-5. Epub 2014 Oct 4.
Upper limb motor blocks (ULMB) (inability to initiate or sudden discontinue in voluntary movements) have been identified in both unimanual and bimanual tasks in individuals with Parkinson's disease (PD). In particular, ULMB have been observed during rhythmic bimanual coordination when switching between phase patterns which is required (e.g. between in-phase and anti-phase). While sensory-perceptual mechanisms have recently been suggested to be involved in lower limb freezing, there has been no consensus on the mechanism that evokes ULMB or whether motor blocks respond to dopamine replacement like other motor symptoms of PD. The current study investigated the occurrence of ULMB in PD participants without ('off') and with ('on') dopamine replacement using bimanual wrist flexion-extension with external auditory cues. In Experiment 1, coordination was performed in either in-phase (simultaneous flexion and extension) or anti-phase (asymmetrical flexion and extension between the limbs) in one of three sensory conditions: no vision, normal vision or augmented vision. Cycle frequency was increased within each trial across seven cycle frequencies (0.75-2 Hz). In Experiment 2, coordination was initiated in either phase pattern and participants were cued to make an intentional switch between phases in the middle of trials. Trials were performed at one of two cycle frequencies (1 or 2 Hz) and one of two sensory conditions: no vision or normal vision. Healthy age-matched control participants were also investigated in both experiments for the occurrence of motor blocks that were measured using automated detection from a computer algorithm. The results from Experiment 1 indicated that increasing cycle frequency resulted in more ULMB in individuals with PD during continuous coordinated movement, regardless of dopaminergic status, phase pattern or sensory condition. Experiment 2 also confirmed an increased occurrence of ULMB with increased cycle frequency. Furthermore, a large amount of ULMB were observed when initiating anti-phase coordination at 2 Hz, as well as after both externally-cued switches and in 'catch trials' with distracting auditory cues when no switch was required. Dopamine replacement was not found to influence the frequency of ULMB in either experiment. Therefore, ULMB likely result from non-hypodopaminergic impairments associated with PD. Specifically, ULMB may be caused by an inability to shift attentional control under increased cognitive demand that could be associated with hypoactivation in motor and prefrontal areas.
上肢运动阻滞(ULMB,即无法发起或突然中断自主运动)在帕金森病(PD)患者的单手和双手任务中均有发现。特别是,在有节奏的双手协调过程中,当在所需的相位模式之间切换时(例如在同相和反相之间),观察到了ULMB。虽然最近有人提出感觉-知觉机制与下肢冻结有关,但对于引发ULMB的机制,或者运动阻滞是否像PD的其他运动症状一样对多巴胺替代有反应,尚未达成共识。本研究使用双手腕屈伸并结合外部听觉提示,调查了未接受多巴胺替代治疗(“关期”)和接受多巴胺替代治疗(“开期”)的PD参与者中ULMB的发生情况。在实验1中,在三种感觉条件之一(无视觉、正常视觉或增强视觉)下,以同相(同时屈伸)或反相(肢体间不对称屈伸)进行协调运动。在每个试验中,循环频率在七个循环频率(0.75 - 2赫兹)范围内增加。在实验2中,以任一相位模式开始协调运动,并提示参与者在试验中间有意地在相位之间进行切换。试验在两个循环频率(1或2赫兹)之一和两种感觉条件之一(无视觉或正常视觉)下进行。在两个实验中,还对年龄匹配的健康对照参与者进行了调查,以检测使用计算机算法自动检测到的运动阻滞情况。实验1的结果表明,在持续的协调运动中,无论多巴胺能状态、相位模式或感觉条件如何,循环频率增加都会导致PD患者出现更多的ULMB。实验2也证实,随着循环频率增加,ULMB的发生率会升高。此外,在以2赫兹开始反相协调运动时,以及在外部提示的切换之后和在不需要切换的“捕捉试验”中出现干扰性听觉提示时,观察到大量的ULMB。在两个实验中均未发现多巴胺替代会影响ULMB的频率。因此,ULMB可能是由与PD相关的非多巴胺能减退损伤引起的。具体而言,ULMB可能是由于在认知需求增加的情况下无法转移注意力控制,这可能与运动和前额叶区域的激活不足有关。