Garde Garcia Hector, Ortiz Oshiro Elena, Ciappara Paniagua Marco, Poma Medrano Liz, Fuentes Ferrer Manuel, Vera Gonzalez Vicente, Moreno Sierra Jesus
Urology Department. Hospital Clinico San Carlos. Madrid. Spain.
Arch Esp Urol. 2014 Oct;67(8):673-83.
To determine the current status of the training of Urology Resident's in Laparoscopic surgery, robotics and endourology.
We performed a survey among Spanish Urology Residents between 2011 and may 2012. We designed a survey that was disseminated through the web page of the Spanish Society of Laparoscopic and Robotic surgery (SECLA) (www.seclaendosurgery.com) to all residents from every Spanish hospital. The survey was divided in four blocks: General data, data of the Training Hospital, data of the surgical procedures (endoscopic, laparoscopic and robotic) and training features. We performed a descriptive study of the results.
36 Urology residents out of a total of 384 answered the survey (9,3%). In reference to endoscopic procedures 25% of the residents had never been involved on a percutaneous nephrostomy (n=36), and did not expect to do it. On the contrary, 77% have performed ureterorrenoscopy as first surgeon (n=36) and 25% have participated in more than 10 procedures. 54.4% of the participants took part as surgeons in percutaneous nephrolithotomies (n=28) and 79% looked forward to do them. Participation of residents in Da Vinci Robot assisted laparoscopic procedures is low. Laparoscopic procedures are very attractive and their participation is reduced as procedure complexity increases.
41.6% of participants think their training is adequate whereas 58,3% think it is not. 88% think their training could improve through courses and seminars and acquiring a greater degree of responsibility.
确定泌尿外科住院医师在腹腔镜手术、机器人手术和腔内泌尿外科方面的培训现状。
2011年至2012年5月期间,我们对西班牙泌尿外科住院医师进行了一项调查。我们设计了一项调查,并通过西班牙腹腔镜与机器人手术学会(SECLA)的网页(www.seclaendosurgery.com)分发给西班牙各医院的所有住院医师。该调查分为四个部分:一般数据、培训医院数据、手术操作(内镜、腹腔镜和机器人手术)数据以及培训特点。我们对结果进行了描述性研究。
在总共384名泌尿外科住院医师中,有36人回答了调查(9.3%)。关于内镜手术,25%的住院医师从未参与过经皮肾造瘘术(n = 36),也不期望进行此类手术。相反,77%的住院医师作为主刀医生进行过输尿管肾镜检查(n = 36),25%的住院医师参与过10例以上此类手术。54.4%的参与者作为外科医生参与过经皮肾镜取石术(n = 28),79%的人期望进行此类手术。住院医师参与达芬奇机器人辅助腹腔镜手术的比例较低。腹腔镜手术很有吸引力,但随着手术复杂性增加,参与度会降低。
41.6%的参与者认为他们的培训是充分的,而58.3%的人认为不充分。88%的人认为通过课程和研讨会以及承担更大的责任,他们的培训可以得到改善。