Green David J, Serrins Jesse D, Seitelman Brielle, Martiny Amy R, Gunz Philipp
Department of Anatomy, Midwestern University, Downers Grove, Illinois.
Anat Rec (Hoboken). 2015 Jan;298(1):180-94. doi: 10.1002/ar.23071.
Recent discoveries of early hominin scapulae from Ethiopia (Dikika, Woranso-Mille) and South Africa (Malapa) have motivated new examinations of the relationship between scapular morphology and locomotor function. In particular, infraspinous fossa shape has been shown to significantly differ among hominoids. However, this region presents relatively few homologous landmarks, such that traditional distance and angle-based methods may oversimplify this three-dimensional structure. To more thoroughly assess infraspinous fossa shape variation as it relates to function among adult hominoid representatives, we considered two geometric morphometric (GM) approaches--one employing five homologous landmarks ("wireframe") and another with 83 sliding semilandmarks along the border of the infraspinous fossa. We identified several differences in infraspinous fossa shape with traditional approaches, particularly in superoinferior fossa breadth and scapular spine orientation. The wireframe analysis reliably captured the range of shape variation in the sample, which reflects the relatively straightforward geometry of the infraspinous fossa. Building on the traditional approach, the GM results highlighted how the orientation of the medial portion of the infraspinous fossa differed relative to both the axillary border and spine. These features distinguished Pan from Gorilla in a way that traditional analyses had not been able to discern. Relative to the wireframe method, the semilandmark approach further distinguished Pongo from Homo, highlighting aspects of infraspinous fossa morphology that may be associated with climbing behaviors in hominoid taxa. These results highlight the ways that GM methods can enhance our ability to evaluate complex aspects of shape for refining and testing hypotheses about functional morphology.
近期在埃塞俄比亚(迪基卡、沃兰索-米莱)和南非(马拉帕)发现的早期人科动物肩胛骨,促使人们对肩胛骨形态与运动功能之间的关系进行新的研究。特别是,已表明类人猿的冈下窝形状存在显著差异。然而,该区域的同源地标相对较少,以至于传统的基于距离和角度的方法可能会过度简化这种三维结构。为了更全面地评估成年类人猿代表中与功能相关的冈下窝形状变化,我们考虑了两种几何形态测量(GM)方法——一种使用五个同源地标(“线框”),另一种沿着冈下窝边界使用83个滑动半地标。我们通过传统方法发现了冈下窝形状的几个差异,特别是在上下窝宽度和肩胛冈方向方面。线框分析可靠地捕捉了样本中的形状变化范围,这反映了冈下窝相对简单的几何形状。在传统方法的基础上,GM结果突出了冈下窝内侧部分相对于腋缘和肩胛冈的方向差异。这些特征以传统分析无法辨别的方式区分了黑猩猩和大猩猩。相对于线框方法,半地标方法进一步区分了猩猩和人类,突出了冈下窝形态的一些方面,这些方面可能与类人猿类群的攀爬行为有关。这些结果突出了GM方法可以增强我们评估形状复杂方面的能力,以完善和检验关于功能形态的假设。