Goeldlin Adrian O, Siegenthaler Andrea, Moser André, Stoeckli Yvette D, Stuck Andreas E, Schoenenberger Andreas W
Division of Geriatrics, Department of General Internal Medicine, Inselspital, Bern University Hospital, and University of Bern, CH-3010 Bern, Switzerland.
BMC Med Educ. 2014 Oct 23;14:233. doi: 10.1186/1472-6920-14-233.
Physicians' attitudes, knowledge and skills are powerful determinants of quality of care for older patients. Previous studies found that using educational interventions to improve attitude is a difficult task. No previous study sought to determine if a skills-oriented educational intervention improved student attitudes towards elderly patients.
This study evaluated the effect of a geriatric clinical skills training (CST) on attitudes of University of Bern medical students in their first year of clinical training. The geriatric CST consisted of four 2.5-hour teaching sessions that covered central domains of geriatric assessment (e.g., cognition, mobility), and a textbook used by students to self-prepare. Students' attitudes were the primary outcome, and were assessed with the 14-item University of California at Los Angeles Geriatrics Attitudes Scale (UCLA-GAS) in a quasi-randomized fashion, either before or after geriatric CST.
A total of 154 medical students participated. Students evaluated before the CST had a median UCLA-GAS overall scale of 49 (interquartile range 44-53). After the CST, the scores increased slightly, to 51 (interquartile range 47-54; median difference 2, 95% confidence interval 0-4, P = 0.062). Of the four validated UCLA-GAS subscales, only the resource distribution subscale was significantly higher in students evaluated after the geriatric CST (median difference 1, 95% confidence interval 0-2, P = 0.005).
Teaching that targets specific skills may improve the attitudes of medical students towards elderly patients, though the improvement was slight. The addition of attitude-building elements may improve the effectiveness of future skills-oriented educational interventions.
医生的态度、知识和技能是老年患者护理质量的有力决定因素。先前的研究发现,利用教育干预来改善态度是一项艰巨的任务。此前没有研究试图确定以技能为导向的教育干预是否能改善学生对老年患者的态度。
本研究评估了老年临床技能培训(CST)对伯尔尼大学临床培训第一年医学生态度的影响。老年CST包括四个2.5小时的教学课程,涵盖老年评估的核心领域(如认知、活动能力),以及学生用于自我准备的一本教科书。学生的态度是主要结果,在老年CST之前或之后,以半随机方式用14项加州大学洛杉矶分校老年医学态度量表(UCLA-GAS)进行评估。
共有154名医学生参与。在CST之前接受评估的学生,UCLA-GAS总体量表的中位数为49(四分位间距44-53)。CST之后,分数略有上升,至51(四分位间距47-54;中位数差异为2,95%置信区间0-4,P = 0.062)。在四个经过验证的UCLA-GAS子量表中,只有资源分配子量表在老年CST之后接受评估的学生中显著更高(中位数差异为1,95%置信区间0-2,P = 0.005)。
针对特定技能的教学可能会改善医学生对老年患者的态度,尽管改善幅度较小。增加态度培养元素可能会提高未来以技能为导向的教育干预的效果。