Dhamija Rajiv, Nash Shawn K, Nguyen Shawn V, Slack Kyle, Tadeo Joseph
Rancho Los Amigos National Rehabilitation Center, Downey, California; Western University of Health Sciences, Pomona, California.
Semin Dial. 2015 May-Jun;28(3):299-304. doi: 10.1111/sdi.12311. Epub 2014 Oct 23.
Hemodialysis vascular access surveillance for hemodynamically significant stenosis can be a challenge because no universal gold standard exists. The StenTec Gauge measures static intra-access peak pressure and graphically displays the ratio of this pressure to systemic systolic (peak) arterial pressure (PIA ratio). In combination with careful physical exam (PE), the StenTec Gauge is an acceptable and cost-effective way of detecting hemodynamically significant stenosis in arteriovenous fistulas (AVF) or grafts (AVG). In a selected population of 21 hemodialysis patients with mature arteriovenous access, a StenTec reading and physical examination was measured on a weekly basis. Interventional procedures for suspected access dysfunction were performed if there was a greater than 25% increase of the PIA ratio from baseline in two consecutive readings, along with correlating clinical suspicion from physical examination findings. StenTec independently had a sensitivity of 56% and a specificity of 99% in detecting clinically significant stenosis. PE alone had a sensitivity of 89% and a specificity of 100%. StenTec combined with PE had a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 99% for predicting hemodynamically significant stenosis. StenTec detected 4 of 10 patients who had a PIA ratio value of ≥0.5, which correlates with current National Kidney Foundation Disease Outcomes Quality Initiative (KDOQI) criteria for mean intra-access pressure ratios indicating a clinically significant outflow stenosis. PE predicted 9 of 10 patients with stenosis, and the combination of StenTec and PE predicted all 10 patients with clinically significant stenosis using the KDOQI criteria for PIA ratio. Hemodynamically significant access stenosis can be detected with excellent accuracy using both StenTec and PE measurements combined for monitoring and surveillance methods.
由于不存在通用的金标准,对血液动力学显著狭窄进行血液透析血管通路监测可能具有挑战性。StenTec测量仪可测量通路内静态峰值压力,并以图形方式显示该压力与全身收缩(峰值)动脉压的比值(PIA比值)。结合仔细的体格检查(PE),StenTec测量仪是检测动静脉内瘘(AVF)或移植物(AVG)中血液动力学显著狭窄的一种可接受且具有成本效益的方法。在21例具有成熟动静脉通路的血液透析患者的特定人群中,每周测量一次StenTec读数和进行体格检查。如果连续两次读数中PIA比值较基线升高超过25%,同时体格检查结果存在相关临床怀疑,则对疑似通路功能障碍进行介入治疗。在检测临床显著狭窄方面,StenTec单独使用时的灵敏度为56%,特异度为99%。单独的体格检查灵敏度为89%,特异度为100%。StenTec与体格检查相结合在预测血液动力学显著狭窄方面的灵敏度为l00%,特异度为99%。StenTec检测出10例PIA比值≥0.5的患者中的4例,这与美国国家肾脏基金会疾病预后质量倡议(KDOQI)目前关于平均通路内压力比值提示临床显著流出道狭窄的标准相关。体格检查预测出10例狭窄患者中的9例,使用KDOQI的PIA比值标准,StenTec与体格检查相结合预测出所有10例临床显著性狭窄患者。将StenTec和体格检查测量结合用于监测和监督方法,能够以极高的准确性检测出血液动力学显著通路狭窄。