Nassimizadeh M, Nassimizadeh A K, Power D
University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2014 Nov;96(8):571-4. doi: 10.1308/003588414X13946184902767.
In September 1998 the world's first hand transplant was performed in Lyon, France. A new era in reconstructive surgery had begun. This case highlighted the potential for composite tissue allotransplantation (CTA). While CTA is not a new technique, it unifies the principles of reconstructive microsurgery and transplant surgery, achieving the goals of absolute correction of a defect with anatomically and physiologically identical tissue with none of the issues of donor site morbidity associated with autologous tissue transfer. The adoption of this technique for non-life threatening conditions to improve quality of life has generated a number of new ethical considerations. Additionally, the prominence of transplanted hands has led to much discussion around the issue of body identity and psychological assessment of potential recipients. This is fundamental to any hand transplantation programme. With the advent of hand transplantation dawning in the UK, we review the many ethical considerations that contribute to this new frontier.
1998年9月,世界上第一例手部移植手术在法国里昂进行。重建外科的新时代由此开启。该病例凸显了复合组织异体移植(CTA)的潜力。虽然CTA并非新技术,但它将重建显微外科和移植外科的原则统一起来,利用解剖学和生理学上相同的组织实现了对缺损的绝对矫正,且不存在与自体组织转移相关的供区并发症问题。将该技术应用于非危及生命的病症以改善生活质量引发了一些新的伦理考量。此外,移植手的突出性引发了围绕身体认同问题以及对潜在接受者进行心理评估的诸多讨论。这对任何手部移植项目而言都是至关重要的。随着英国手部移植的出现,我们审视了促成这一新领域的诸多伦理考量。