Research Institute of Psychoanalysis, Department of Applied Psychology, City University of Macau, Avenida Xian Xing Hai, Ed.Golden Dragon Centre, 4° andar, Macau.
Behav Sci (Basel). 2013 Nov 22;3(4):662-675. doi: 10.3390/bs3040662. eCollection 2013 Dec.
Post-Jungians tend to identify Jung's dream theory with the concept of compensation; they tend to believe that Jung's radically open stand constitutes his dream theory in its entirety. However, Jung's theory regarding dreams was a product of an evolving process throughout his whole intellectual and professional life. Unfortunately, the theory has not been understood in such a developmental light. Based on a historical and textual study of all dream articles found throughout The Collected Works of C.G. Jung, this paper maps a concise three-phase trajectory of Jung's changing views on dreams and interpretation. The paper posits that Jung's last essay, "Symbols and the Interpretation of Dreams" (1961), epitomizes his final stand, although such a stand is also reflected in a less explicit and less emphatic way during the latter period of the second phase. The paper also briefly addresses where Jung and Jungians have been enigmatic or negligent. For example, it has not been explicated fully why compensation as slight modifications and compensation as parallels to waking life situations are rare in Jung's cases In addition, contemporary cognitive and neuroscientific approaches to the study of dreams, as represented by Harry Hunt, William Domhoff, and Allan Hobson, among others, are presented in connection with Jung. The juxtaposition of Jungian, cognitive, and neuroscientific approaches showcases how cognitive and scientific findings challenge, enrich, and in some ways confirm Jung's dream theory and praxis.
后荣格派倾向于将荣格的梦理论与补偿概念联系起来;他们倾向于认为荣格激进的开放性立场构成了他的梦理论的全部。然而,荣格的梦理论是他整个知识和职业生涯中不断发展的产物。不幸的是,这个理论并没有被理解为一个发展的过程。本文通过对荣格《荣格全集》中所有梦文章的历史和文本研究,勾勒出荣格对梦和解释的看法不断变化的简明三阶段轨迹。本文认为,荣格的最后一篇论文《象征与梦的解释》(1961 年),是他最终立场的缩影,尽管这种立场在第二阶段后期也以不那么明确和不那么强调的方式反映出来。本文还简要探讨了荣格和荣格主义者在哪些方面含糊不清或疏忽大意。例如,荣格的案例中为什么补偿作为轻微的修改和补偿作为与清醒生活情况的平行现象很少,这一点并没有得到充分的解释。此外,本文还介绍了以哈里·亨特、威廉·多夫曼和艾伦·霍布森等人为代表的当代认知和神经科学对梦的研究方法,与荣格的方法并列。荣格、认知和神经科学方法的并列展示了认知和科学发现如何挑战、丰富并在某些方面证实了荣格的梦理论和实践。