Case-Smith Jane, Weaver Lindy, Holland Terri
Jane Case-Smith, EdD, OT/L, FAOTA, was Professor and Director, Occupational Therapy Division, The Ohio State University, Columbus, at the time of the study.
Lindy Weaver, MOT, OTR/L, is PhD Candidate, Occupational Therapy Division, The Ohio State University, 406 Atwell Hall, 453 West 10th Avenue, Columbus, OH 43210;
Am J Occup Ther. 2014 Nov-Dec;68(6):690-8. doi: 10.5014/ajot.2014.011585.
This study examined the effectiveness of Write Start, a handwriting and writing program cotaught by teachers and occupational therapists for first-grade children. Four classrooms (n = 80) received the Write Start program, and four (n = 58) received standard handwriting and writing instruction. Two teachers and an occupational therapist implemented the 24-session manualized program, which included station teaching and individualized supports. The program emphasized practice in small groups in which the coteaching team provided students with frequent feedback, encouraged self-evaluation, and facilitated peer modeling and peer evaluation. Students who completed the Write Start program improved more in handwriting legibility and speed than the group receiving standard instruction. Writing fluency and written composition were no different between groups at posttest; however, writing fluency was significantly higher for Write Start students at 6-mo follow-up. Write Start students with low legibility at baseline made significant improvements, suggesting that the program may benefit students at risk for handwriting and writing problems.
本研究考察了“书写起步”(Write Start)项目的效果,该项目是由教师和职业治疗师共同为一年级儿童开展的一项书法与写作课程。四个班级(n = 80)接受了“书写起步”项目,另外四个班级(n = 58)接受了标准的书法与写作教学。两名教师和一名职业治疗师实施了这个为期24节的标准化课程,其中包括站点教学和个性化支持。该课程强调小组练习,在小组练习中,联合教学团队会频繁地为学生提供反馈,鼓励自我评价,并促进同伴示范和同伴评价。完成“书写起步”项目的学生在书写清晰度和速度方面的进步比接受标准教学的小组更大。在后测中,两组在写作流畅性和书面作文方面没有差异;然而,在6个月的随访中,“书写起步”项目的学生写作流畅性显著更高。基线时书写清晰度较低的“书写起步”项目学生取得了显著进步,这表明该项目可能会使有书法和写作问题风险的学生受益。