Johnson David R, Helbling Damian E, Lee Tae Kwon, Park Joonhong, Fenner Kathrin, Kohler Hans-Peter E, Ackermann Martin
Department of Environmental Systems Science, ETH Zürich, Zürich, Switzerland Department of Environmental Microbiology, Eawag, Dübendorf, Switzerland
Department of Environmental Microbiology, Eawag, Dübendorf, Switzerland School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York, USA.
Appl Environ Microbiol. 2015 Jan;81(2):666-75. doi: 10.1128/AEM.03286-14. Epub 2014 Nov 14.
Biodiversities can differ substantially among different wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) communities. Whether differences in biodiversity translate into differences in the provision of particular ecosystem services, however, is under active debate. Theoretical considerations predict that WWTP communities with more biodiversity are more likely to contain strains that have positive effects on the rates of particular ecosystem functions, thus resulting in positive associations between those two variables. However, if WWTP communities were sufficiently biodiverse to nearly saturate the set of possible positive effects, then positive associations would not occur between biodiversity and the rates of particular ecosystem functions. To test these expectations, we measured the taxonomic biodiversity, functional biodiversity, and rates of 10 different micropollutant biotransformations for 10 full-scale WWTP communities. We have demonstrated that biodiversity is positively associated with the rates of specific, but not all, micropollutant biotransformations. Thus, one cannot assume whether or how biodiversity will associate with the rate of any particular micropollutant biotransformation. We have further demonstrated that the strongest positive association is between biodiversity and the collective rate of multiple micropollutant biotransformations. Thus, more biodiversity is likely required to maximize the collective rates of multiple micropollutant biotransformations than is required to maximize the rate of any individual micropollutant biotransformation. We finally provide evidence that the positive associations are stronger for rare micropollutant biotransformations than for common micropollutant biotransformations. Together, our results are consistent with the hypothesis that differences in biodiversity can indeed translate into differences in the provision of particular ecosystem services by full-scale WWTP communities.
不同污水处理厂(WWTP)群落之间的生物多样性可能存在很大差异。然而,生物多样性的差异是否会转化为特定生态系统服务提供方面的差异,仍在激烈争论中。理论考量预测,生物多样性更高的污水处理厂群落更有可能包含对特定生态系统功能速率有积极影响的菌株,从而导致这两个变量之间存在正相关关系。然而,如果污水处理厂群落的生物多样性足够高,几乎使可能的积极影响集达到饱和,那么生物多样性与特定生态系统功能速率之间就不会出现正相关关系。为了检验这些预期,我们测量了10个全规模污水处理厂群落的分类生物多样性、功能生物多样性以及10种不同微污染物生物转化的速率。我们已经证明,生物多样性与特定但并非所有微污染物生物转化的速率呈正相关。因此,人们无法假定生物多样性是否会以及如何与任何特定微污染物生物转化的速率相关联。我们进一步证明,最强的正相关关系存在于生物多样性与多种微污染物生物转化的总速率之间。因此,与使任何单个微污染物生物转化速率最大化相比,可能需要更多的生物多样性才能使多种微污染物生物转化的总速率最大化。我们最终提供的证据表明,对于罕见微污染物生物转化而言,正相关关系比常见微污染物生物转化更强。总体而言,我们的结果与以下假设一致,即生物多样性的差异确实可以转化为全规模污水处理厂群落提供特定生态系统服务方面的差异。