Bank Ilana, Snell Linda, Bhanji Farhan
From the *Division of Pediatric Emergency Medicine, †Arnold and Blema Steinberg Medical Simulation Center, ‡Center for Medical Education, §Division of General Internal Medicine, and ∥Department of Pediatrics, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Pediatr Emerg Care. 2014 Dec;30(12):879-83. doi: 10.1097/PEC.0000000000000302.
Improved pediatric crisis resource management (CRM) training is needed in emergency medicine residencies because of the variable nature of exposure to critically ill pediatric patients during training. We created a short, needs-based pediatric CRM simulation workshop with postactivity follow-up to determine retention of CRM knowledge. Our aims were to provide a realistic learning experience for residents and to help the learners recognize common errors in teamwork and improve their perceived abilities to manage ill pediatric patients.
Residents participated in a 4-hour objectives-based workshop derived from a formal needs assessment. To quantify their subjective abilities to manage pediatric cases, the residents completed a postworkshop survey (with a retrospective precomponent to assess perceived change). Ability to identify CRM errors was determined via a written assessment of scripted errors in a prerecorded video observed before and 1 month after completion of the workshop.
Fifteen of the 16 eligible emergency medicine residents (postgraduate year 1-5) attended the workshop and completed the surveys. There were significant differences in 15 of 16 retrospective pre to post survey items using the Wilcoxon rank sum test for non-parametric data. These included ability to be an effective team leader in general (P < 0.008), delegating tasks appropriately (P < 0.009), and ability to ensure closed-loop communication (P < 0.008). There was a significant improvement in identification of CRM errors through the use of the video assessment from 3 of the 12 CRM errors to 7 of the 12 CRM errors (P < 0.006).
The pediatric CRM simulation-based workshop improved the residents' self-perceptions of their pediatric CRM abilities and improved their performance on a video assessment task.
由于急诊医学住院医师培训期间接触危重症儿科患者的情况各不相同,因此需要改进儿科危机资源管理(CRM)培训。我们创建了一个简短的、基于需求的儿科CRM模拟工作坊,并在活动后进行跟进,以确定CRM知识的保留情况。我们的目标是为住院医师提供真实的学习体验,并帮助学习者识别团队合作中的常见错误,提高他们管理患病儿科患者的感知能力。
住院医师参加了一个基于正式需求评估的4小时目标导向工作坊。为了量化他们管理儿科病例的主观能力,住院医师完成了工作坊后的调查(包括一个回顾性的前期部分,以评估感知到的变化)。通过对工作坊开始前和结束后1个月观看的一段预录制视频中的脚本错误进行书面评估,确定识别CRM错误的能力。
16名符合条件的急诊医学住院医师(研究生1-5年级)中有15人参加了工作坊并完成了调查。使用非参数数据的Wilcoxon秩和检验,16项回顾性前后调查项目中有15项存在显著差异。这些差异包括总体上成为有效团队领导者的能力(P < 0.008)、适当分配任务的能力(P < 0.009)以及确保闭环沟通的能力(P < 0.008)。通过视频评估识别CRM错误的能力有显著提高,从12个CRM错误中的3个提高到12个CRM错误中的7个(P < 0.006)。
基于模拟的儿科CRM工作坊提高了住院医师对自身儿科CRM能力的自我认知,并提高了他们在视频评估任务中的表现。