Thomas Kimberly, Rahimi Asal, Spangler Ann, Anderson John, Garwood Dan
Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Moncrief Radiation Oncology Center, Dallas, Texas.
Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Moncrief Radiation Oncology Center, Dallas, Texas.
Pract Radiat Oncol. 2014 Nov-Dec;4(6):466-71. doi: 10.1016/j.prro.2014.04.002. Epub 2014 Jun 2.
For patients requiring radiation therapy following mastectomy or breast reconstruction, there often exist much heterogeneity among practitioners with respect to radiation technique.
A 14-question survey was sent nationwide to 1000 active email addresses from the American Society for Radiation Oncology member directory; 271 radiation oncologists completed the survey.
A total of 75.2% of respondents indicate that they do not routinely deflate the ipsilateral tissue expander (TE) prior to radiation, while 11.5% do routinely deflate (P ≤ .01); 52.2% indicate that they typically use bolus when treating their patients with TEs following mastectomy, 36.7% do not, and 11.1% on a case by case basis (P ≤ .01). Of respondents indicating bolus utilization, 32.8% use a bolus of 0.5 cm every other day; 31.4% indicate a bolus of 0.5 cm every day until tolerated; 20.4% use a bolus of 1 cm every other day; 5.8% indicate a bolus of 1 cm every day until tolerated; and 9.5% indicate a customized bolus approach (P ≤ .01). A total of 22.9% of respondents deliver boost to all patients with TE while 42.9% deliver boost only to select patients, and 33.5% indicate no utilization of boost (P ≤ .01). A total of 33.1% indicate that collaborating surgeons routinely place clips at the lumpectomy cavity at the time of breast reduction or complex tissue rearrangement, while 38.3% indicate that clips are occasionally placed, and 28.6% stated clips are not routinely placed (P = .15); 38.7% of respondents routinely deliver a boost for patients undergoing breast reduction only if clips have been placed in the tumor cavity, while 34.6% indicate that a boost is used regardless of clip placement.
Radiation treatments with tissue expanders have become common practice, but details of radiation treatment vary widely. Radiation oncologist and breast surgeons should continue to work to optimize radiation techniques and allow proper localization for radiation boost.
对于乳房切除术后或乳房重建后需要放疗的患者,放疗技术在从业者之间往往存在很大差异。
向美国放射肿瘤学会会员名录中的1000个有效电子邮件地址发送了一份包含14个问题的调查问卷;271名放射肿瘤学家完成了调查。
共有75.2%的受访者表示,他们在放疗前通常不会常规性地对同侧组织扩张器(TE)进行放气,而11.5%的受访者会常规放气(P≤0.01);52.2%的受访者表示,在对乳房切除术后使用TE的患者进行治疗时,他们通常会使用填充物,36.7%的受访者不使用,11.1%的受访者根据具体情况使用(P≤0.01)。在表示使用填充物的受访者中,32.8%每隔一天使用0.5厘米厚的填充物;31.4%表示每天使用0.5厘米厚的填充物,直到患者耐受;20.4%每隔一天使用1厘米厚的填充物;5.8%表示每天使用1厘米厚的填充物,直到患者耐受;9.5%表示采用定制的填充物方法(P≤0.01)。共有22.9%的受访者对所有使用TE的患者进行强化放疗,42.9%的受访者仅对部分患者进行强化放疗,33.5%的受访者表示不进行强化放疗(P≤0.01)。共有33.1%的受访者表示,协作的外科医生在乳房缩小术或复杂组织重排时会常规在肿块切除腔内放置夹子,38.3%的受访者表示偶尔放置,28.6%的受访者表示不常规放置(P = 0.15);38.7%的受访者表示,仅在肿瘤腔内放置夹子的情况下,才会对接受乳房缩小术的患者常规进行强化放疗,而34.6%的受访者表示无论是否放置夹子都会使用强化放疗。
使用组织扩张器进行放疗已成为常见做法,但放疗细节差异很大。放射肿瘤学家和乳腺外科医生应继续努力优化放疗技术,并为强化放疗实现正确定位。