Kane Jeremy C, Ventevogel Peter, Spiegel Paul, Bass Judith K, van Ommeren Mark, Tol Wietse A
Department of Mental Health, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, 624 North Broadway, Room 894, Baltimore, MD, 21205, USA.
Division of Programme Support and Management, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, Geneva, Switzerland.
BMC Med. 2014 Nov 24;12:228. doi: 10.1186/s12916-014-0228-9.
Population-based epidemiological research has established that refugees in low- and middle-income countries (LMIC) are at increased risk for a range of mental, neurological and substance use (MNS) problems. Improved knowledge of rates for MNS problems that are treated in refugee camp primary care settings is needed to identify service gaps and inform resource allocation. This study estimates contact coverage of MNS services in refugee camps by presenting rates of visits to camp primary care centers for treatment of MNS problems utilizing surveillance data from the Health Information System (HIS) of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.
Data were collected between January 2009 and March 2013 from 90 refugee camps across 15 LMIC. Visits to primary care settings were recorded for seven MNS categories: epilepsy/seizure; alcohol/substance use; mental retardation/intellectual disability; psychotic disorder; emotional disorder; medically unexplained somatic complaint; and other psychological complaint. The proportion of MNS visits attributable to each of the seven categories is presented by country, sex and age group. The data were combined with camp population data to generate rates of MNS visits per 1,000 persons per month, an estimate of contact coverage.
Rates of visits for MNS problems ranged widely across countries, from 0.24 per 1,000 persons per month in Zambia to 23.69 in Liberia. Rates of visits for epilepsy were higher than any of the other MNS categories in nine of fifteen countries. The largest proportion of MNS visits overall was attributable to epilepsy/seizure (46.91% male/35.13% female) and psychotic disorders (25.88% male/19.98% female). Among children under five, epilepsy/seizure (82.74% male/82.29% female) also accounted for the largest proportion of MNS visits.
Refugee health systems must be prepared to manage severe neuropsychiatric disorders in addition to mental conditions associated with stress. Relatively low rates of emotional and substance use visits in primary care, compared to high prevalence of such conditions in epidemiological studies suggest that many MNS problems remain unattended by refugee health services. Wide disparity in rates across countries warrants additional investigation into help seeking behaviors of refugees and the capacity of health systems to correctly identify and manage diverse MNS problems.
基于人群的流行病学研究表明,低收入和中等收入国家(LMIC)的难民面临一系列精神、神经和物质使用(MNS)问题的风险增加。需要更好地了解难民营初级保健机构中接受治疗的MNS问题发生率,以确定服务差距并为资源分配提供依据。本研究利用联合国难民事务高级专员公署健康信息系统(HIS)的监测数据,通过呈现前往难民营初级保健中心治疗MNS问题的就诊率,来估计难民营中MNS服务的接触覆盖率。
2009年1月至2013年3月期间,收集了来自15个低收入和中等收入国家90个难民营的数据。记录了七个MNS类别的初级保健就诊情况:癫痫/惊厥;酒精/物质使用;智力发育迟缓/智力残疾;精神障碍;情绪障碍;医学上无法解释的躯体主诉;以及其他心理主诉。按国家、性别和年龄组列出七个类别中每类MNS就诊的比例。将这些数据与难民营人口数据相结合,得出每月每1000人的MNS就诊率,即接触覆盖率的估计值。
各国MNS问题的就诊率差异很大,从赞比亚的每月每1000人0.24例到利比里亚的23.69例不等。在15个国家中的9个国家,癫痫的就诊率高于任何其他MNS类别。总体而言,MNS就诊的最大比例归因于癫痫/惊厥(男性46.91%/女性35.13%)和精神障碍(男性25.88%/女性19.98%)。在五岁以下儿童中,癫痫/惊厥(男性82.74%/女性82.29%)也占MNS就诊的最大比例。
难民卫生系统除了要应对与压力相关的精神状况外,还必须做好管理严重神经精神障碍的准备。与流行病学研究中此类疾病的高患病率相比,初级保健中情绪和物质使用就诊率相对较低,这表明许多MNS问题仍未得到难民卫生服务的关注。各国就诊率的巨大差异值得进一步调查难民的求助行为以及卫生系统正确识别和管理各种MNS问题的能力。