Cox Georgina R, Callahan Patch, Churchill Rachel, Hunot Vivien, Merry Sally N, Parker Alexandra G, Hetrick Sarah E
Orygen Youth Health Research Centre, Centre for Youth Mental Health, University of Melbourne, Locked Bag 10, 35 Poplar Road, Parkville, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia, 3054.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2014 Nov 30;2014(11):CD008324. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008324.pub3.
BACKGROUND: Depressive disorders are common in children and adolescents and, if left untreated, are likely to recur in adulthood. Depression is highly debilitating, affecting psychosocial, family and academic functioning. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the effectiveness of psychological therapies and antidepressant medication, alone and in combination, for the treatment of depressive disorder in children and adolescents. We have examined clinical outcomes including remission, clinician and self reported depression measures, and suicide-related outcomes. SEARCH METHODS: We searched the Cochrane Depression, Anxiety and Neurosis Review Group's Specialised Register (CCDANCTR) to 11 June 2014. The register contains reports of relevant randomised controlled trials (RCTs) from the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), MEDLINE (1950 to date), EMBASE (1974 to date), and PsycINFO (1967 to date). SELECTION CRITERIA: RCTs were eligible for inclusion if they compared i) any psychological therapy with any antidepressant medication, or ii) a combination of psychological therapy and antidepressant medication with a psychological therapy alone, or an antidepressant medication alone, or iii) a combination of psychological therapy and antidepressant medication with a placebo or'treatment as usual', or (iv) a combination of psychological therapy and antidepressant medication with a psychological therapy or antidepressant medication plus a placebo.We included studies if they involved participants aged between 6 and 18 years, diagnosed by a clinician as having Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) based on Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) or International Classification of Diseases (ICD) criteria. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: Two review authors independently selected studies, extracted data and assessed the quality of the studies. We applied a random-effects meta-analysis, using the odds ratio (OR) to describe dichotomous outcomes, mean difference (MD) to describe continuous outcomes when the same measures were used, and standard mean difference (SMD) when outcomes were measured on different scales. MAIN RESULTS: We included eleven studies, involving 1307 participants in this review. We also identified one ongoing study, and two additional ongoing studies that may be eligible for inclusion. Studies recruited participants with different severities of disorder and with a variety of comorbid disorders, including anxiety and substance use disorder, therefore limiting the comparability of the results. Regarding the risk of bias in studies, just under half the studies had adequate allocation concealment (there was insufficient information to determine allocation concealment in the remainder), outcome assessors were blind to the participants' intervention in six studies, and in general, studies reported on incomplete data analysis methods, mainly using intention-to-treat (ITT) analyses. For the majority of outcomes there were no statistically significant differences between the interventions compared. There was limited evidence (based on two studies involving 220 participants) that antidepressant medication was more effective than psychotherapy on measures of clinician defined remission immediately post-intervention (odds ratio (OR) 0.52, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.27 to 0.98), with 67.8% of participants in the medication group and 53.7% in the psychotherapy group rated as being in remission. There was limited evidence (based on three studies involving 378 participants) that combination therapy was more effective than antidepressant medication alone in achieving higher remission from a depressive episode immediately post-intervention (OR 1.56, 95% CI 0.98 to 2.47), with 65.9% of participants treated with combination therapy and 57.8% of participants treated with medication, rated as being in remission. There was no evidence to suggest that combination therapy was more effective than psychological therapy alone, based on clinician rated remission immediately post-intervention (OR 1.82, 95% CI 0.38 to 8.68).Suicide-related Serious Adverse Events (SAEs) were reported in various ways across studies and could not be combined in meta-analyses. However, some trials measured suicidal ideation using standardised assessment tools suitable for meta-analysis. In one study involving 188 participants, rates of suicidal ideation were significantly higher in the antidepressant medication group (18.6%) compared with the psychological therapy group (5.4%) (OR 0.26, 95% CI 0.09 to 0.72) and this effect appeared to remain at six to nine months (OR 0.26, 95% CI 0.07 to 0.98), with 13.6% of participants in the medication group and 3.9% of participants in the psychological therapy group reporting suicidal ideation. It was unclear what the effect of combination therapy was compared with either antidepressant medication alone or psychological therapy alone on rates of suicidal ideation. The impact of any of the assigned treatment packages on drop out was also mostly unclear across the various comparisons in the review.Limited data and conflicting results based on other outcome measures make it difficult to draw conclusions regarding the effectiveness of any specific intervention based on these outcomes. AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: There is very limited evidence upon which to base conclusions about the relative effectiveness of psychological interventions, antidepressant medication and a combination of these interventions. On the basis of the available evidence, the effectiveness of these interventions for treating depressive disorders in children and adolescents cannot be established. Further appropriately powered RCTs are required.
背景:抑郁症在儿童和青少年中很常见,如果不治疗,成年后很可能复发。抑郁症极具致残性,会影响心理社会、家庭和学业功能。 目的:评估心理治疗和抗抑郁药物单独及联合使用对儿童和青少年抑郁症的治疗效果。我们研究了包括缓解情况、临床医生和自我报告的抑郁量表以及与自杀相关的结果等临床结局。 检索方法:我们检索了Cochrane抑郁、焦虑和神经症综述小组的专业注册库(CCDANCTR)至2014年6月11日。该注册库包含来自Cochrane对照试验中心注册库(CENTRAL)、MEDLINE(1950年至今)、EMBASE(1974年至今)和PsycINFO(1967年至今)的相关随机对照试验(RCT)报告。 入选标准:如果RCT比较了以下情况,则符合纳入标准:i)任何心理治疗与任何抗抑郁药物;ii)心理治疗和抗抑郁药物联合与单独的心理治疗、单独的抗抑郁药物;iii)心理治疗和抗抑郁药物联合与安慰剂或“常规治疗”;iv)心理治疗和抗抑郁药物联合与心理治疗或抗抑郁药物加安慰剂。如果研究涉及6至18岁的参与者,且临床医生根据《诊断与统计手册》(DSM)或《国际疾病分类》(ICD)标准诊断为重度抑郁症(MDD),则纳入研究。 数据收集与分析:两位综述作者独立选择研究、提取数据并评估研究质量。我们采用随机效应荟萃分析,使用比值比(OR)描述二分结局,当使用相同测量方法时用均值差(MD)描述连续结局,当结局在不同量表上测量时用标准化均值差(SMD)。 主要结果:我们纳入了11项研究,本综述涉及1307名参与者。我们还确定了一项正在进行的研究,以及另外两项可能符合纳入标准的正在进行的研究。研究招募了不同严重程度的疾病患者以及患有多种共病的患者,包括焦虑和物质使用障碍,因此限制了结果的可比性。关于研究中的偏倚风险,不到一半的研究有充分的分配隐藏(其余研究没有足够信息确定分配隐藏情况),六项研究中结局评估者对参与者的干预不知情,总体而言,研究报告的数据分析方法不完整,主要使用意向性分析(ITT)。对于大多数结局,所比较的干预措施之间没有统计学上的显著差异。有有限的证据(基于两项涉及220名参与者的研究)表明,在干预后立即由临床医生定义的缓解测量中,抗抑郁药物比心理治疗更有效(比值比(OR)0.52,95%置信区间(CI)0.27至0.98),药物组67.8%的参与者和心理治疗组53.7%的参与者被评为缓解。有有限的证据(基于三项涉及378名参与者的研究)表明,联合治疗在干预后立即从抑郁发作中实现更高缓解方面比单独使用抗抑郁药物更有效(OR 1.56,95% CI 0.98至2.47),联合治疗组65.9%的参与者和药物治疗组57.8%的参与者被评为缓解。基于干预后立即由临床医生评定的缓解情况,没有证据表明联合治疗比单独的心理治疗更有效(OR 1.82,95% CI 0.38至8.68)。自杀相关的严重不良事件(SAEs)在各研究中的报告方式各异,无法在荟萃分析中合并。然而,一些试验使用适合荟萃分析的标准化评估工具测量自杀意念。在一项涉及188名参与者的研究中,抗抑郁药物组的自杀意念发生率(18.6%)显著高于心理治疗组(5.4%)(OR 0.26,95% CI 0.09至0.72),且这种效应在6至9个月时似乎仍然存在(OR 0.26,95% CI 0.07至0.98),药物组13.6%的参与者和心理治疗组3.9%的参与者报告有自杀意念。与单独使用抗抑郁药物或单独使用心理治疗相比,联合治疗对自杀意念发生率的影响尚不清楚。在综述中的各种比较中,任何指定治疗方案对退出率的影响大多也不清楚。基于其他结局测量的有限数据和相互矛盾的结果,很难就任何特定干预措施的有效性得出结论。 作者结论:关于心理干预、抗抑郁药物以及这些干预措施联合使用的相对有效性,几乎没有证据可供得出结论。基于现有证据,无法确定这些干预措施对治疗儿童和青少年抑郁症的有效性。需要进一步开展有足够样本量的随机对照试验。
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2014-11-30
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012-11-14
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2021-5-24
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016-4-4
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2014-9-11
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2018-5-14
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2018-8-15
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2014-11-7
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012-11-14
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2014-11-1
Front Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2024-6-7
Front Psychiatry. 2024-5-1
Int J Ment Health Syst. 2023-3-24
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022-11-30
Aust Prescr. 2022-4
Early Interv Psychiatry. 2015-4
Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2013-7
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012-11-14
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012-11-14
Psychol Res Behav Manag. 2011-8-1
Drug Alcohol Depend. 2011-8-31