Anastopoulou Ioanna, Eliopoulos Constantine, Valakos Efstratios D, Manolis Sotiris K
Department of Animal & Human Physiology, Faculty of Biology, National & Kapodistrian University of Athens, Panepistimiopolis, 157 84 Athens, Greece; Department of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology, School of Medicine, National & Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece.
Research Centre in Evolutionary Anthropology and Palaeoecology, School of Natural Sciences and Psychology, Liverpool John Moores University, Byrom Street, Liverpool L3 3AF, United Kingdom.
Forensic Sci Int. 2014 Dec;245:203.e1-4. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2014.10.005. Epub 2014 Oct 14.
The existence of sexual dimorphism in individual elements of the human skeleton allows sex determination and significantly enhances the identification of fragmentary skeletal material. Traditionally, the pelvis and the skull are used for an accurate sex determination. Sometimes they are not available and alternative methods have to be used. The aim of this work is to study the sexual dimorphism of the proximal portion of the posterior femur by analyzing the biometric data of the Purkait's triangle. The studied sample comprises 203 individuals (112 males and 91 females) from the Modern Human Skeletal Reference Collection (The Athens Collection) of the Department of Animal & Human Physiology (National & Kapodistrian University of Athens). The biometric data were analyzed by Discriminant Analysis and equations were generated for sex determination, which gave an overall correct classification of 78.3%. For the right and the left femur the percentages of correct classification were 77.8% and 75.9% respectively. These accuracy rates were compared to those of an Indian population and were found to be lower (86.5% for males and 86.3% for females). The study of sexual dimorphism (SD) in Greek, Indian, European-American and African-American populations gave interesting results. The AB diameter in the Greek sample shows the lowest degree of SD while the AC diameter shows the highest. In the other three population samples, the BC diameter shows the highest degree of SD. We assume that the femur anatomy of the Greeks is the major cause that the Purkait method does not give high rates of correct classification. It is therefore advisable that practitioners exercise caution when using this method on skeletal material from Greece, especially in forensic contexts.
人类骨骼个别部位存在的性别二态性有助于进行性别鉴定,并显著提高对骨骼碎片材料的识别能力。传统上,骨盆和头骨用于准确的性别鉴定。有时无法获取这些部位,就必须采用其他方法。这项工作的目的是通过分析普尔凯特三角的生物测量数据来研究股骨后部近端的性别二态性。所研究的样本包括来自动物与人类生理学系(雅典国立与卡波迪斯特里亚大学)现代人类骨骼参考收藏(雅典收藏)的203个人(112名男性和91名女性)。通过判别分析对生物测量数据进行分析,并生成用于性别鉴定的方程,总体正确分类率为78.3%。对于右侧和左侧股骨,正确分类的百分比分别为77.8%和75.9%。将这些准确率与印度人群的准确率进行比较,发现较低(男性为86.5%,女性为86.3%)。对希腊、印度、欧美和非裔美国人种群的性别二态性(SD)研究得出了有趣的结果。希腊样本中的AB直径显示出最低程度的性别二态性,而AC直径显示出最高程度。在其他三个人口样本中,BC直径显示出最高程度的性别二态性。我们认为希腊人的股骨解剖结构是普尔凯特方法未能给出高正确分类率的主要原因。因此,从业者在对来自希腊的骨骼材料使用此方法时应谨慎行事,尤其是在法医背景下。