Hensley Melissa, Mateo-Babiano Derlie, Minnery John
School of Geography, Planning and Environmental Management, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Qld 4072, Australia.
Health Promot J Austr. 2014 Dec;25(3):196-201. doi: 10.1071/HE14042.
Children walking to school, people cycling to the shops or work and neighbours chatting in the street, these are some of the gauges of an active and healthy community that can be achieved through utilising good design principles. But are these principles being applied in urban developments or are policy-makers following a 'path dependent' trajectory that severely limits the best practice outcomes sought? This review examines current research on path dependence to determine how this concept advances our understanding of barriers to change in the built environment, active transport and healthy communities. An online database search of scholarly bibliographic records identified 22 relevant articles for a critical review of studies that evaluated path dependence in the urban and built environment literature with a focus on transport, urban planning and health. A thematic analysis of the articles showed that different types of path dependence have contributed to the dominance of policies and designs supporting car-based transport to the detriment of public transport and active transport modes, leading to sub-optimal development patterns becoming 'locked-in'. However, the outcomes for active transport and physical activity are not all dire, and path dependence theory does provide some guidance on changing policy to achieve better outcomes. This review suggests that path dependence is one of the best theoretical frameworks to help health promoters understand barriers to change and can provide insights into developing future successful public health interventions. Future studies could focus further on active transport, local neighbourhood development and physical activity.
孩子们步行上学、人们骑车去商店或上班以及邻居们在街上聊天,这些都是一个积极健康社区的一些指标,而这些指标可以通过运用良好的设计原则来实现。但是这些原则是否被应用于城市发展中呢?政策制定者们是否遵循着一条“路径依赖”的轨迹,从而严重限制了所追求的最佳实践成果呢?这篇综述考察了当前关于路径依赖的研究,以确定这一概念如何增进我们对建筑环境、主动式交通和健康社区变革障碍的理解。通过对学术文献记录的在线数据库搜索,确定了22篇相关文章,用于对评估城市和建筑环境文献中路径依赖的研究进行批判性综述,重点关注交通、城市规划和健康。对这些文章的主题分析表明,不同类型的路径依赖导致了支持汽车交通的政策和设计占据主导地位,损害了公共交通和主动式交通模式,导致次优发展模式被“锁定”。然而,主动式交通和身体活动的结果并非全是糟糕的,路径依赖理论确实为改变政策以实现更好的结果提供了一些指导。这篇综述表明,路径依赖是帮助健康促进者理解变革障碍的最佳理论框架之一,并且可以为制定未来成功的公共卫生干预措施提供见解。未来的研究可以进一步关注主动式交通、当地社区发展和身体活动。