Leonard Kenneth E, Winters Jamie J, Kearns-Bodkin Jill N, Homish Gregory G, Kubiak Audrey J
Research Institute on Addictions, University at Buffalo, SUNY.
Department of Psychiatry, University of Michigan and VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System.
Psychol Violence. 2014 Oct;4(4):384-398. doi: 10.1037/a0037483.
Research examining dyadic patterns of intimate partner violence (IPV) often focuses on static conceptions based on whether either the husband or wife has exhibited any violence. This study examined the dyadic patterns of IPV empirically and traced how these groups change over time.
Couples (N=634) were assessed with respect to IPV and relationship satisfaction at the time of marriage, and at their first and second anniversaries. Cluster analysis was conducted on Total Aggression, Differential Aggression, and the Aggression Ratio prior to marriage for couples with any violence.
This analysis revealed 5 clusters; Very High-Husband to Wife, (High:H>W); Very High-Wife to Husband (High-W>H); Low to Moderate, Husband to Wife (Low:H>W); Low to Moderate, Wife to Husband (Low-W>H); Low to Moderate, Both Aggressive (Low:H=W). The majority (57%) of the aggressive couples were classified in the gender asymmetric groups. Most asymmetric clusters became symmetric over time, but the High:H>W cluster became more asymmetric. By the 2 anniversary, all clusters were characterized by higher injuries experienced by wives than by husbands.
These results demonstrate that a considerable amount of IPV that is typically classified as "bidirectional" is gender asymmetric and that these asymmetric patterns tend to converge into more symmetric patterns over time.
关于亲密伴侣暴力(IPV)二元模式的研究通常聚焦于基于丈夫或妻子是否表现出任何暴力行为的静态概念。本研究对IPV的二元模式进行了实证研究,并追踪了这些群体随时间的变化情况。
对634对夫妻在结婚时、结婚一周年和两周年时进行了IPV及关系满意度评估。对有暴力行为的夫妻在婚前的总攻击行为、差异攻击行为和攻击比率进行聚类分析。
该分析揭示了5个类别;丈夫对妻子的极高攻击型(高:丈夫>妻子);妻子对丈夫的极高攻击型(高:妻子>丈夫);丈夫对妻子的低到中度攻击型(低:丈夫>妻子);妻子对丈夫的低到中度攻击型(低:妻子>丈夫);双方低到中度攻击型(低:丈夫=妻子)。大多数(57%)有攻击行为的夫妻被归类为性别不对称组。随着时间的推移,大多数不对称类别变得对称,但丈夫对妻子的极高攻击型类别变得更加不对称。到结婚两周年时,所有类别中妻子遭受的伤害都高于丈夫。
这些结果表明,大量通常被归类为“双向”的IPV是性别不对称的,并且随着时间的推移,这些不对称模式倾向于收敛为更对称的模式。