Hornik Robert C, Yanovitzky Itzhak
University of Pennsylvania.
Commun Theory. 2003 May;13(2):204-224. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-2885.2003.tb00289.x.
We present a general theory about how campaigns can have effects and suggest that the evaluation of communication campaigns must be driven by a theory of effects. The National Youth Anti-Drug Media Campaign illustrates both the theory of campaign effects and implications that theory has for the evaluation design. Often models of effect assume that individual exposure affects cognitions that continue to affect behavior over a short term. Contrarily, effects may operate through social or institutional paths as well as through individual learning, require substantial levels of exposure achieved through multiple channels over time, take time to accumulate detectable change, and affect some members of the audience but not others. Responsive evaluations will choose appropriate units of analysis and comparison groups, data collection schedules sensitive to lagged effects, samples able to detect subgroup effects, and analytic strategies consistent with the theory of effects that guides the campaign.
我们提出了一个关于宣传活动如何产生效果的通用理论,并指出宣传活动的评估必须由效果理论驱动。全国青少年反毒品媒体宣传活动既阐释了宣传活动效果理论,也说明了该理论对评估设计的影响。通常,效果模型假定个体接触会影响认知,而这些认知会在短期内持续影响行为。相反,效果可能通过社会或制度途径以及个体学习来发挥作用,需要随着时间的推移通过多种渠道实现大量接触,需要时间来积累可察觉的变化,并且会影响部分受众成员而非其他成员。响应式评估将选择合适的分析单位和比较组、对滞后效果敏感的数据收集时间表、能够检测亚组效果的样本,以及与指导宣传活动的效果理论相一致的分析策略。