Geisbush Tom R, Visyak Nicole, Madabusi Lavanya, Rutkove Seward B, Darras Basil T
Department of Neurology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
Boston Children's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
Clin Neurophysiol. 2015 Sep;126(9):1790-6. doi: 10.1016/j.clinph.2014.11.017. Epub 2014 Nov 28.
High reliability is a prerequisite for any test to be useful as a biomarker in a clinical trial. Here we assessed the reproducibility of electrical impedance myography (EIM) in children by comparing data obtained by different evaluators on separate days.
Healthy boys and boys with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) aged 2-14 years underwent EIM of multiple muscles performed by two evaluators on two visits separated by 3-7 days. Single and multifrequency data were analyzed. Reliability was assessed via calculation of the percent relative standard deviation (% RSD), Bland-Altman analysis, and the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC).
For both individual muscle data and data averaged across muscles, intra-evaluator measurements showed high repeatability for both 50 kHz phase and 50/200 kHz phase ratio values, with ICCs generally above 0.90 and % RSD below 10%. Inter-evaluator results showed very similar ICC and % RSD values as those obtained by the same evaluator.
Both the 50 kHz phase and 50/200 kHz phase ratio are reliable measures both across time and evaluators and in both health and disease.
These results support the concept that EIM can serve as a reliable measure in clinical therapeutic trials in a pediatric population.
高可靠性是任何一项测试在临床试验中作为生物标志物发挥作用的前提条件。在此,我们通过比较不同评估者在不同日期获得的数据,评估了儿童电阻抗肌电图(EIM)的可重复性。
2至14岁的健康男孩和患有杜氏肌营养不良症(DMD)的男孩接受了EIM检查,由两名评估者在两次相隔3至7天的就诊中对多块肌肉进行检查。对单频和多频数据进行了分析。通过计算相对标准偏差百分比(%RSD)、布兰德-奥特曼分析和组内相关系数(ICC)来评估可靠性。
对于个体肌肉数据和多块肌肉的平均数据,评估者内部测量显示,50kHz相位和50/200kHz相位比值均具有较高的重复性,ICC通常高于0.90,%RSD低于10%。评估者间的结果显示,ICC和%RSD值与同一评估者获得的结果非常相似。
50kHz相位和50/200kHz相位比值在时间、评估者以及健康和疾病状态下都是可靠的测量指标。
这些结果支持了EIM可作为儿科人群临床治疗试验中可靠测量指标的概念。