Abdulkareem Imran Haruna
Department of Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgery, Leeds University Teaching Hospitals, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom.
Niger Med J. 2014 Nov;55(6):443-51. doi: 10.4103/0300-1652.144692.
The concept of surgical waiting time initiative (SWAT) was introduced in developed countries to reduce elective surgery waiting lists and increase efficiency of care. It was supplemented by increasing popularity of day surgery, which shortens elective waiting lists and minimises cancellations. It is established in Western countries, but not in developing countries like Nigeria where it is still evolving. A search was carried out in Pub Med, Google, African journals online (AJOL), Athens and Ovid for relevant publications on elective surgery waiting list in Nigeria, published in English language. Words include waiting/wait time, waiting time initiative, time to surgery, waiting for operations, waiting for intervention, waiting for procedures and time before surgery in Nigeria. A total of 37 articles published from Nigeria in relation to various waiting times were found from the search and fulfilled the inclusion criteria. Among them, 11 publications (29.7%) were related to emergency surgery waiting times, 10 (27%) were related to clinic waiting times, 9 (24.3%) were related to day case surgery, 2 (5.5%) were related to investigation waiting times and only 5 (13.5%) articles were specifically published on elective surgery waiting times. A total of 9 articles (24.5%) were published from obstetrics and gynaecology (OG), 7 (19%) from general surgery, 5 (13.5%) from public health, 3 (8%) from orthopaedics, 3 (8%) from general practice (GP), 3 (8%) from paediatrics/paediatric surgery, 2 (5.5%) from ophthalmology, 1 (2.7%) from ear, nose and throat (ENT), 1 (2.7%) from plastic surgery, 1 (2.7%) from urology and only 1 (2.7%) article was published from dental/maxillofacial surgery. Waiting times mean different things to different health practitioners in Nigeria. There were only 5/37 articles (13.5%) specifically related to elective surgery waiting times in Nigerian hospitals, which show that the concept of the SWAT is still evolving in Nigeria. Of the 37, 11 (24.5%) publications were from obstetrics and gynaecology (O & G) alone, but these were mostly related to emergency antenatal care rather than surgery. Therefore, more research and initiative needs to be undertaken from all the surgical sub-specialties in order to disseminate this concept of SWAT towards early diagnosis and treatment of elective life-threatening conditions, as well as effective patient care. Adopting this concept will help healthcare managers and policy makers to stream line and ring face resources to cater for non-urgent or semi-urgent cases presenting to our hospitals in Nigeria.
手术等待时间倡议(SWAT)的概念在发达国家被引入,以减少择期手术等待名单并提高护理效率。日间手术越来越受欢迎对其起到了补充作用,日间手术缩短了择期等待名单并将取消手术的情况降至最低。这一概念在西方国家已确立,但在尼日利亚等发展中国家仍在发展中。我们在PubMed、谷歌、非洲在线期刊(AJOL)、雅典和Ovid上进行了搜索,查找以英文发表的关于尼日利亚择期手术等待名单的相关出版物。搜索词包括等待/等待时间、等待时间倡议、手术时间、等待手术、等待干预、等待程序以及尼日利亚的手术前时间。通过搜索,共找到37篇来自尼日利亚的与各种等待时间相关的文章,这些文章符合纳入标准。其中,11篇出版物(29.7%)与急诊手术等待时间相关,10篇(27%)与门诊等待时间相关,9篇(24.3%)与日间手术相关,2篇(5.5%)与检查等待时间相关,只有5篇(13.5%)文章专门关于择期手术等待时间。共有9篇文章(24.5%)来自妇产科(OG),7篇(19%)来自普通外科,5篇(13.5%)来自公共卫生,3篇(8%)来自骨科,3篇(8%)来自全科医学(GP),3篇(8%)来自儿科/小儿外科,2篇(5.5%)来自眼科,1篇(2.7%)来自耳鼻喉科(ENT),1篇(2.7%)来自整形外科,1篇(2.7%)来自泌尿外科,只有1篇(2.7%)文章来自牙科/颌面外科。在尼日利亚,等待时间对不同的医疗从业者意味着不同的事情。在这37篇文章中,只有5篇(13.5%)专门与尼日利亚医院的择期手术等待时间相关,这表明SWAT的概念在尼日利亚仍在发展中。在这37篇文章中,仅妇产科(O&G)就有11篇(24.5%)出版物,但这些大多与急诊产前护理而非手术相关。因此,所有外科亚专业都需要开展更多研究和倡议,以传播SWAT这一概念,实现对择期危及生命疾病的早期诊断和治疗以及有效的患者护理。采用这一概念将有助于医疗管理者和政策制定者优化和重新分配资源,以应对尼日利亚医院中出现的非紧急或半紧急病例。