Singh Sanjay, Madaki Aboi J K, Jiya Nma M, Singh Rupashree, Thacher Tom D
Department of Family Medicine, Usmanu Danfodiyo University Teaching Hospital, Sokoto, Nigeria.
Department of Family Medicine, Jos University Teaching Hospital, Jos, Nigeria.
Niger Med J. 2014 Nov;55(6):480-5. doi: 10.4103/0300-1652.144701.
Presumptive diagnosis of malaria is widespread, even where microscopy is available. As fever is very nonspecific, this often leads to over diagnosis, drug wastage and loss of opportunity to consider alternative causes of fever, hence the need to improve on the clinical diagnosis of malaria.
In a prospective cross-sectional comparative study, we examined 45 potential predictors of uncomplicated malaria in 800 febrile children (0-12 years) in Sokoto, Nigeria. We developed a clinical algorithm for malaria diagnosis and compared it with a validated algorithm, Olaleye's model.
Malaria was confirmed in 445 (56%). In univariate analysis, 13 clinical variables were associated with malaria. In multivariate analysis, vomiting (odds ratio, OR 2.6), temperature ≥ 38.5°C (OR 2.2), myalgia (OR 1.8), weakness (OR 1.9), throat pain (OR 1.8) and absence of lung crepitations (OR 5.6) were independently associated with malaria. In children over age 3 years, any 3 predictors had a sensitivity of 82% and specificity of 47% for malaria. An Olaleye score ≥ 5 had a sensitivity of 62% and a specificity of 51%.
In hyperendemic areas, the sensitivity of our algorithm may permit presumptive diagnosis of malaria in children. Algorithm positive cases can be presumptively treated, and negative cases can undergo parasitological testing to determine need for treatment.
即使在可进行显微镜检查的地方,疟疾的推定诊断也很普遍。由于发热非常不具特异性,这常常导致过度诊断、药物浪费以及错过考虑发热其他病因的机会,因此有必要改进疟疾的临床诊断。
在一项前瞻性横断面比较研究中,我们对尼日利亚索科托的800名发热儿童(0至12岁)的45个非复杂性疟疾潜在预测因素进行了检查。我们开发了一种疟疾诊断临床算法,并将其与经过验证的算法奥拉莱耶模型进行比较。
445例(56%)确诊为疟疾。在单变量分析中,13个临床变量与疟疾相关。在多变量分析中,呕吐(比值比,OR 2.6)、体温≥38.5°C(OR 2.2)、肌痛(OR 1.8)、虚弱(OR 1.9)、咽痛(OR 1.8)以及无肺部啰音(OR 5.6)与疟疾独立相关。在3岁以上儿童中,任何3个预测因素对疟疾的敏感度为82%,特异度为47%。奥拉莱耶评分≥5的敏感度为62%,特异度为51%。
在高度流行地区,我们的算法的敏感度可能允许对儿童疟疾进行推定诊断。算法阳性的病例可进行推定治疗,阴性病例可进行寄生虫学检测以确定是否需要治疗。