Akhavan A A, Veysi A, Arandian M H, Vatandoost H, Yaghoobi-Ershadi M R, Hosseini M, Abdoli H, Heidari K, Sadjadi A, Fadaei R, Ramazanpour J, Aminian K, Shirzadi M R, Jafari R
Esfahan Health Research Station, National Institute of Health Research, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Esfahan, Iran.
J Vector Borne Dis. 2014 Dec;51(4):307-12.
BACKGROUND & OBJECTIVES: ZCL is a growing threat in many rural areas of Iran which involves 17 out of 31 provinces. This study was conducted from April to November 2011 for evaluation of the efficacy of phostoxin and zinc phosphide against rodents.
Rodent control operations were carried out using phostoxin and zinc phosphide. To evaluate the effect of rodent control operation on the main vector density, an entomological survey was carried out. The effects of the operation on the disease incidence were also evaluated.
After intervention, the reduction rate of rodent burrows was 32.68% in the village treated with phostoxin and 58.14% in the village treated with zinc phosphide. The number of rodent holes in the control area showed 6.66-fold increase at the end of the study. The incidence of the disease decreased to 19.23 and 11.40 in areas treated with phostoxin and zinc phosphide, respectively. A total of 4243 adult sandflies were collected and identified. The most common and dominant species was Phlebotomus papatasi. In the village treated with phostoxin, the density of P. papatasi in outdoors was lower than indoors. Nevertheless, the density of P. papatasi in the village treated with zinc phosphide was higher in outdoors.
INTERPRETATION & CONCLUSION: It is concluded that phostoxin is less effective and has low safety in comparison with zinc phosphide, so that this rodenticide can be used only in special situations such as lack or ineffective rodenticides and only in the colonies far from human and animal dwelling places in small scales.
在伊朗的许多农村地区,泽卡病(ZCL)构成的威胁日益严重,伊朗31个省份中有17个受其影响。本研究于2011年4月至11月开展,旨在评估磷化铝和磷化锌对啮齿动物的灭鼠效果。
采用磷化铝和磷化锌开展灭鼠行动。为评估灭鼠行动对主要病媒密度的影响,进行了一项昆虫学调查。同时还评估了该行动对疾病发病率的影响。
干预后,使用磷化铝处理的村庄中啮齿动物洞穴减少率为32.68%,使用磷化锌处理的村庄中为58.14%。研究结束时,对照区啮齿动物洞穴数量增加了6.66倍。在使用磷化铝和磷化锌处理的地区,疾病发病率分别降至19.23和11.40。共采集并鉴定了4243只成年白蛉。最常见且占主导地位的物种是巴氏白蛉。在使用磷化铝处理的村庄,户外巴氏白蛉的密度低于室内。然而,在使用磷化锌处理的村庄,户外巴氏白蛉的密度更高。
得出的结论是,与磷化锌相比,磷化铝效果较差且安全性低,因此这种灭鼠剂仅可在诸如灭鼠剂短缺或无效等特殊情况下,且仅在远离人类和动物居住场所的小规模聚居地使用。