Huang Tzu-Hsueh, Ning Xinghai, Wang Xiaojian, Murthy Niren, Tzeng Yih-Ling, Dickson Robert M
School of Chemistry & Biochemistry, Petit Institute for Bioengineering and Bioscience, Georgia Institute of Technology , Atlanta, Georgia 30305-0400, United States.
Anal Chem. 2015 Feb 3;87(3):1941-9. doi: 10.1021/ac504241x. Epub 2015 Jan 13.
Flow cytometry holds promise to accelerate antibiotic susceptibility determinations; however, without robust multidimensional statistical analysis, general discrimination criteria have remained elusive. In this study, a new statistical method, probability binning signature quadratic form (PB-sQF), was developed and applied to analyze flow cytometric data of bacterial responses to antibiotic exposure. Both sensitive lab strains (Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa) and a multidrug resistant, clinically isolated strain (E. coli) were incubated with the bacteria-targeted dye, maltohexaose-conjugated IR786, and each of many bactericidal or bacteriostatic antibiotics to identify changes induced around corresponding minimum inhibition concentrations (MIC). The antibiotic-induced damages were monitored by flow cytometry after 1-h incubation through forward scatter, side scatter, and fluorescence channels. The 3-dimensional differences between the flow cytometric data of the no-antibiotic treated bacteria and the antibiotic-treated bacteria were characterized by PB-sQF into a 1-dimensional linear distance. A 99% confidence level was established by statistical bootstrapping for each antibiotic-bacteria pair. For the susceptible E. coli strain, statistically significant increments from this 99% confidence level were observed from 1/16x MIC to 1x MIC for all the antibiotics. The same increments were recorded for P. aeruginosa, which has been reported to cause difficulty in flow-based viability tests. For the multidrug resistant E. coli, significant distances from control samples were observed only when an effective antibiotic treatment was utilized. Our results suggest that a rapid and robust antimicrobial susceptibility test (AST) can be constructed by statistically characterizing the differences between sample and control flow cytometric populations, even in a label-free scheme with scattered light alone. These distances vs paired controls coupled with rigorous statistical confidence limits offer a new path toward investigating initial biological responses, screening for drugs, and shortening time to result in antimicrobial sensitivity testing.
流式细胞术有望加快抗生素敏感性测定;然而,若没有强大的多维统计分析,通用的判别标准仍难以捉摸。在本研究中,开发了一种新的统计方法——概率分箱特征二次型(PB-sQF),并将其应用于分析细菌对抗生素暴露反应的流式细胞术数据。将敏感的实验室菌株(大肠杆菌和铜绿假单胞菌)以及一株多重耐药的临床分离菌株(大肠杆菌)与靶向细菌的染料——麦芽六糖共轭IR786,以及多种杀菌或抑菌抗生素分别孵育,以识别在相应最低抑菌浓度(MIC)附近诱导的变化。孵育1小时后,通过流式细胞术,利用前向散射、侧向散射和荧光通道监测抗生素诱导的损伤。通过PB-sQF将未用抗生素处理的细菌与用抗生素处理的细菌的流式细胞术数据之间的三维差异表征为一维线性距离。通过对每对抗生素-细菌进行统计自展法建立了99%的置信水平。对于敏感的大肠杆菌菌株,所有抗生素在从1/16×MIC到1×MIC的范围内,均观察到该99%置信水平有统计学意义的增加。铜绿假单胞菌也记录到了相同的增加,据报道该菌在基于流式的活力测试中存在困难。对于多重耐药的大肠杆菌,仅在使用有效抗生素治疗时,才观察到与对照样品有显著差异。我们的结果表明,即使在仅利用散射光的无标记方案中,通过对样品和对照流式细胞术群体之间的差异进行统计表征,也可以构建快速且可靠的抗菌药敏试验(AST)。这些与配对对照的差异以及严格的统计置信限为研究初始生物学反应、药物筛选以及缩短抗菌敏感性测试结果报告时间提供了一条新途径。