Sharp Brian, Singal Bonita, Pulia Michael, Fowler Jennifer, Simmons Stefanie
Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, WI.
Acad Emerg Med. 2015 Jan;22(1):47-53. doi: 10.1111/acem.12564. Epub 2014 Dec 24.
The hypothesis was that a reminder about recommended primary care physician (PCP) follow-up, sent via e-mail to patients discharged from the emergency department (ED), would increase the proportion of patients who followed up with their PCPs within the recommended time frame. Patient receptiveness to e-mail follow-up reminders was also assessed.
This was a mixed methods clinical intervention study with subjects randomized either to receive the usual care discharge instructions only or to also receive a reminder e-mail message the day after the ED visit. The reminder e-mail contained the subject's PCP's name and address and the recommended PCP follow-up time interval. A blinded review of outpatient PCP medical records was conducted to determine whether and when follow-up occurred. Researchers attempted to contact patients with a telephone survey 2 weeks after their ED visits. The primary outcomes between groups were compared using chi-square tests and relative risks (RRs) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs).
Thirty-three percent of the intervention group and 32% of the control group followed-up as recommended (RR = 1.04, 95% CI = 0.81 to 1.33); 52% of the intervention group and 48% of the control group followed-up within 10 days of the recommended time (RR = 1.08, 95% CI = 0.91 to 1.29). The 334 patients (57%) successfully contacted via telephone demonstrated a high interest in receiving future e-mail reminders (75%), with the group that received e-mail reminders more likely to want one in the future than those who did not receive e-mail reminders (82.5% vs. 69.76%; p = 0.04).
E-mail reminders sent after ED visits did not improve patients' adherence to the recommended timing of primary care follow-up contained in discharge instructions. Subjects in both the control and the intervention groups favorably viewed the concept of e-mail reminders, suggesting that the value of e-mail reminders after ED discharge may be in areas such as patient satisfaction that were not specifically targeted for measurement in this study.
研究假设为,通过电子邮件向急诊科(ED)出院患者发送关于推荐的初级保健医生(PCP)随访的提醒,会提高在推荐时间范围内进行PCP随访的患者比例。同时还评估了患者对电子邮件随访提醒的接受程度。
这是一项混合方法的临床干预研究,受试者被随机分为两组,一组仅接受常规护理出院指导,另一组在急诊就诊后次日还会收到一封提醒电子邮件。提醒电子邮件包含受试者PCP的姓名和地址以及推荐的PCP随访时间间隔。对门诊PCP病历进行盲法审查,以确定是否以及何时进行了随访。研究人员在患者急诊就诊2周后试图通过电话调查联系他们。使用卡方检验和95%置信区间(CI)的相对风险(RR)比较两组之间的主要结局。
干预组33%的患者和对照组32% 的患者按推荐进行了随访(RR = 1.04,95% CI = 0.81至1.33);干预组52%的患者和对照组48%的患者在推荐时间的10天内进行了随访(RR = 1.08,95% CI = 0.91至1.29)。通过电话成功联系的334名患者(57%)对未来接收电子邮件提醒表现出高度兴趣(75%),与未收到电子邮件提醒的患者相比,收到电子邮件提醒的患者未来更有可能希望收到提醒(82.5%对69.76%;p = 0.04)。
急诊就诊后发送的电子邮件提醒并未提高患者对出院指导中推荐的初级保健随访时间的依从性。对照组和干预组的受试者都对电子邮件提醒的概念持积极态度,这表明急诊出院后电子邮件提醒的价值可能体现在患者满意度等方面,而这些方面在本研究中并未作为具体的测量目标。