Cornell Institute for Public Affairs, Cornell University , Ithaca, New York 14853, United States.
Environ Sci Technol. 2015 Feb 3;49(3):1260-7. doi: 10.1021/es505007m. Epub 2015 Jan 23.
We investigated the implications of behind-the-meter (BTM) generation participating in demand response (DR) programs. Specifically, we evaluated the impacts of NOx emissions from BTM generators enrolled in the New York Independent System Operator (NYISO)'s reliability-based DR programs. Through analyzing the DR program enrollment data, DR event records, ozone air quality monitoring data, and emission characteristics of the generators, we found that the emissions from BTM generators very likely contribute to exceedingly high ozone concentrations in the Northeast Corridor region, and very likely account for a substantial fraction of total NOx emissions from electricity generation. In addition, a companion study showed that the emissions from BTM generators could also form near-source particulate matter (PM) hotspots. The important policy implications are that the absence of up-to-date regulations on BTM generators may offset the current efforts to reduce the emissions from peaking power plants, and that there is a need to quantify the environmental impacts of DR programs in designing sound policies related to demand-side resources. Furthermore, we proposed the concept of "Green" DR resources, referring to those that not only provide power systems reliability services, but also have verifiable environmental benefits or minimal negative environmental impacts. We argue that Green DR resources that are able to maintain resource adequacy and reduce emissions at the same time are key to achieving the cobenefits of power system reliability and protecting public health during periods with peak electricity demand.
我们研究了参与需求响应(DR)计划的幕后(BTM)发电的影响。具体来说,我们评估了参与纽约独立系统运营商(NYISO)基于可靠性的 DR 计划的 BTM 发电机的氮氧化物排放的影响。通过分析 DR 计划注册数据、DR 事件记录、臭氧空气质量监测数据和发电机的排放特征,我们发现 BTM 发电机的排放很可能导致东北走廊地区极高的臭氧浓度,并且很可能占发电总氮氧化物排放量的很大一部分。此外,一项配套研究表明,BTM 发电机的排放也可能形成近源颗粒物(PM)热点。重要的政策意义是,缺乏有关 BTM 发电机的最新法规可能会抵消当前减少高峰期发电厂排放的努力,并且有必要在设计与需求侧资源相关的合理政策时量化 DR 计划的环境影响。此外,我们提出了“绿色”DR 资源的概念,指的是那些不仅提供电力系统可靠性服务,而且具有可验证的环境效益或最小的负面环境影响的资源。我们认为,同时能够维持资源充足和减少排放的绿色 DR 资源是在用电高峰期实现电力系统可靠性和保护公众健康的共同效益的关键。