Magnavital Nicola, Garbarino Sergio, Siegrist Johannes
Dipartimento di Sanità Pubblica, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Roma.
G Ital Med Lav Ergon. 2014 Oct-Dec;36(4):400-4.
Stress in police: assessment methods.
Police work is unanimously considered stressful. Prevention of stress in police is of the utmost importance, as a distressed officer could be hazardous for third parties. There is scientific evidence that the relationship between occupational stressors and their psychological and physical consequences can be described by Karasek's demand-control-support (DCS) model and the effort / reward imbalance (ERI) model of Siegrist.
This study summarizes the results of surveys conducted using the DCS and ERI questionnaires.on police officers from the VI Mobile Unit of Genoa who were engaged in public order management at the G8 summit in L'Aquila in 2009.
In spite of the high alert due to expected threats to public order during the G8 meeting, police officers were not affected by "distress". When the policemen were compared to other categories of workers, their stress levels were in the lowest range. In most cases, the personality profile of these workers did not differ substantially from that of the general population. There was an association between personality and stress response. The levels of perceived stress were significantly associated with absence from work. The prevalence of mental disorders in police officers was significantly lower than that of the general population. Occupational stress was associated with indicators of depression, anxiety and burnout.
The DCS and ERI models yielded complementary results and proved to be effective in assessing the effects of stress in law enforcement. The extent of perceived stress does not directly depend on external events, but on the way in which these are handled: routine work may be more stressful than a single critical event. Special police forces are particularly resilient to stress, partly due to the characteristics and personality of individual officers, but mainly on account of their training. Occupational stress is associated with a lower level of psychological well-being and an increase in the frequency of absences from work.
警察工作中的压力:评估方法
警察工作被一致认为压力巨大。预防警察工作中的压力至关重要,因为情绪低落的警察可能会对第三方造成危险。有科学证据表明,职业压力源与其心理和生理后果之间的关系可以用 Karasek 的需求 - 控制 - 支持(DCS)模型以及 Siegrist 的努力/回报失衡(ERI)模型来描述。
本研究总结了使用 DCS 和 ERI 问卷对来自热那亚第六机动部队的警察进行调查的结果。这些警察于 2009 年在拉奎拉八国集团峰会期间参与公共秩序管理工作。
尽管由于八国集团会议期间预期的公共秩序威胁而处于高度戒备状态,但警察并未受到“困扰”。与其他类别的工人相比,警察的压力水平处于最低范围。在大多数情况下,这些警察的性格特征与普通人群并无实质性差异。性格与压力反应之间存在关联。感知到的压力水平与缺勤显著相关。警察中精神障碍的患病率明显低于普通人群。职业压力与抑郁、焦虑和倦怠指标相关。
DCS 和 ERI 模型产生了互补的结果,并被证明在评估执法工作中的压力影响方面是有效的。感知到的压力程度并不直接取决于外部事件,而是取决于处理这些事件的方式:日常工作可能比单个关键事件压力更大。特种警察部队对压力具有特别的适应能力,部分原因是个别警察的特征和性格,但主要是由于他们的训练。职业压力与较低的心理健康水平以及缺勤频率增加有关。