Zhang Xiaolong, Hu Yong, Nie Zhiyu, Song Ye, Pan Yougui, Liu Ying, Jin Lingjing
Department of Neurology, Shanghai Tongji Hospital, Tongji University School of Medicine, Xin-Cun Road 389, Shanghai, 200065, China.
Neurol Sci. 2015 Jul;36(7):1225-31. doi: 10.1007/s10072-015-2084-6. Epub 2015 Jan 24.
Raynaud's phenomenon (RP), an episodic vasospasm of the peripheral arteries, is quite common in general population. The current therapies of RP are limited by efficacy, side effects, and polypharmacy concerns. Botulinum toxin type A (BTX-A) local injections have been reported for the treatment of RP, but the injection sites, concentration and dose of BTX-A were different from each other in previous trials. In addition, so far, there have been no reports concerning local injection of BTX-A in Asian RP patients. Ten patients with RP in China were included in this retrospective study. All the patients had intractable pain and were non-responsive to conservative and/or medical therapy. A patterned BTX-A injection was performed in RP patients, guided by ultrasonography. BTX-A was injected as 20 u/ml devoid of preservatives. Outcomes were measured by ultrasonography, surface temperature, visual analog scale (VAS) for clinical symptoms (pain, numbness, stiffness and swelling), and changes in ulcers or gangrene. Overall, a great improvement in artery flow velocity (P < 0.01), surface temperature (P < 0.01), ulcer and VAS for clinical symptoms, was observed after BTX-A local injection. Complications were very rarely found, and no patients complained of hand weakness and bruise. BTX-A patterned injection guided by ultrasonography might be a useful therapeutic tool in the management of intractable RP.
雷诺现象(RP)是一种外周动脉的发作性血管痉挛,在普通人群中相当常见。目前RP的治疗方法受到疗效、副作用和联合用药问题的限制。已有报道称A型肉毒杆菌毒素(BTX-A)局部注射可用于治疗RP,但在以往试验中,BTX-A的注射部位、浓度和剂量各不相同。此外,迄今为止,尚无关于亚洲RP患者BTX-A局部注射的报道。本回顾性研究纳入了10例中国的RP患者。所有患者均有顽固性疼痛,且对保守治疗和/或药物治疗无反应。在超声引导下对RP患者进行了BTX-A的规范化注射。BTX-A以不含防腐剂的20 U/ml进行注射。通过超声检查、表面温度、临床症状(疼痛、麻木、僵硬和肿胀)的视觉模拟量表(VAS)以及溃疡或坏疽的变化来衡量治疗效果。总体而言,BTX-A局部注射后,动脉血流速度(P < 0.01)、表面温度(P < 0.01)、溃疡情况以及临床症状的VAS均有显著改善。并发症很少见,且没有患者抱怨手部无力和瘀伤。超声引导下的BTX-A规范化注射可能是治疗顽固性RP的一种有用的治疗手段。