MacPherson Hugh, Newbronner Elizabeth, Chamberlain Ruth, Hopton Ann
Department of Health Sciences, University of York, York, UK.
Firefly Research & Evaluation and Visiting Fellow, Department of Health Sciences, University of York, York, UK.
Chiropr Man Therap. 2015 Jan 16;23(1):3. doi: 10.1186/s12998-014-0049-0. eCollection 2015.
Not enough is understood about patients' views of chiropractic care. The aims of this research were to explore patients' experiences and expectations, their perceptions of benefits and risks, and the implications for chiropractors' continuing fitness to practise.
Survey questions were formulated from existing literature, published guidance on good practice from the General Chiropractic Council, and from 28 telephone interviews and a small focus group with chiropractic patients using a semi-structured topic guide. In its final form, the survey elicited patients' ratings on expectations regarding 33 aspects of care. In a national cross-sectional survey, a number of sampling methods were required as a consequence of the low practitioner response rate.
In total, 544 completed questionnaires were received from chiropractic patients, a lower response rate than expected (8%). The two main benefits that patients reported regarding their chiropractic care were reduced pain (92%) and increased mobility (80%). Of respondents, 20% reported unexpected or unpleasant reactions to their treatment, most commonly tiredness or fatigue (32%), and extra pain (36%). In most cases they expressed low levels of concern about these reactions. Patients' expectations were met for most aspects of care. The four aspects of practice where expectations were least well met comprised: having more information on the cost of the treatment plan at the first consultation (80%); the chiropractor contacting the patient's general practitioner if necessary (62%); having a discussion about a referral to another healthcare practitioner (62%); and providing a method for confidential feedback (66%).
Overall, patients reported a high level of satisfaction with the benefits of their chiropractic care, although there is a likelihood of bias towards patients with a positive experience of chiropractic. There were no serious adverse reactions; however, patients reported concern about pain, tingling and numbness in the limbs after chiropractic. In general, patients' expectations were being well met.
对于患者对整脊治疗的看法,我们了解得还不够。本研究的目的是探讨患者的经历和期望、他们对益处和风险的认知,以及对整脊师持续执业适宜性的影响。
根据现有文献、整脊总会发布的良好实践指南,以及对28名整脊患者进行的电话访谈和一个小型焦点小组讨论,使用半结构化主题指南制定了调查问卷。最终形式的调查收集了患者对33个护理方面期望的评分。在一项全国性横断面调查中,由于从业者回复率较低,需要采用多种抽样方法。
总共收到了544份整脊患者填写的问卷,回复率低于预期(8%)。患者报告的整脊治疗的两个主要益处是疼痛减轻(92%)和活动能力增强(80%)。20%的受访者报告了对治疗的意外或不愉快反应,最常见的是疲倦或疲劳(32%)以及额外疼痛(36%)。在大多数情况下,他们对这些反应的担忧程度较低。护理的大多数方面都满足了患者的期望。期望最未得到满足的四个实践方面包括:在首次咨询时获得更多关于治疗计划费用的信息(80%);整脊师在必要时联系患者的全科医生(62%);讨论转诊至另一位医疗从业者(62%);以及提供保密反馈的方式(66%)。
总体而言,患者对整脊治疗的益处高度满意,尽管可能存在对整脊有积极体验的患者的偏差。没有严重的不良反应;然而,患者报告了整脊后对肢体疼痛、刺痛和麻木的担忧。总体而言,患者的期望得到了较好的满足。