Bezdjian Serena, Whedon James M, Goehl Justin M, Kazal Louis A
Health Services Research, Southern California University of Health Sciences, Whittier, CA.
Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth, Hanover, NH.
J Chiropr Med. 2021 Mar;20(1):1-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jcm.2021.02.003. Epub 2021 May 12.
The purpose of this study was to examine experiences and attitudes toward care offered by chiropractors and prescription drug therapy offered by medical physicians for patients who have back pain.
A cross-sectional survey measured patients with back pain (n = 150) seeking care within an academic primary care setting. A survey assessed patient experiences, beliefs, and attitudes regarding chiropractic care and prescription drug therapy. Two samples of patients in the New Hampshire region included 75 patients treated by a doctor of chiropractic (DC) and 75 treated by a medical primary care physician (PCP). The 30-item survey was sent to existing and new patients between February 2019 and January 2020. Between-group comparisons were examined to test rates of reporting and to determine the mean difference in the total number of office visits between the 2 samples.
Patients treated by both DCs and PCPs reported high overall satisfaction with chiropractic care received for low back pain with no significant differences between groups. The majority in both groups reported that seeing a DC for back pain made sense to them (95% of patients treated by a DC and 75% of patients treated by a PCP) whereas the minority reported that taking prescription drugs for back pain made sense (25% of patients treated by a DC and 41% of patients treated by a PCP). There was no statistical difference between groups when patients were asked if seeing a chiropractor changed their beliefs or behaviors about taking pain medication. Significant differences were found between groups for agreement that chiropractic care would be a suitable treatment for back pain (79% of patients treated by a DC and 45% of patients treated by a PCP). There were 7% of patients treated by PCP and 23% of the patients treated by DC who agreed that a DC would be the first health care provider they would like to see for their general health needs.
In this sample of patients, patient satisfaction regarding chiropractic care received for back pain was high. There were differences between patient groups about preferences for treatment for back pain. Our results indicate that patients reported that seeing a DC for back pain did not change their beliefs or behaviors regarding prescription drug therapy provided by their medical PCP.
本研究旨在调查背痛患者对脊椎按摩师提供的护理以及内科医生提供的处方药治疗的体验和态度。
一项横断面调查对在学术性初级保健机构寻求治疗的背痛患者(n = 150)进行了测量。一项调查评估了患者对脊椎按摩护理和处方药治疗的体验、信念和态度。新罕布什尔地区的两组患者包括75名接受脊椎按摩师(DC)治疗的患者和75名接受初级保健内科医生(PCP)治疗的患者。这份包含30个条目的调查问卷在2019年2月至2020年1月期间发送给了现有患者和新患者。进行组间比较以测试报告率,并确定两个样本之间门诊就诊总次数的平均差异。
接受DC和PCP治疗的患者对因腰痛接受的脊椎按摩护理总体满意度都很高,两组之间无显著差异。两组中的大多数人表示,因背痛看DC对他们来说是有意义的(接受DC治疗的患者中有95%,接受PCP治疗的患者中有75%),而少数人表示因背痛服用处方药是有意义的(接受DC治疗的患者中有25%,接受PCP治疗的患者中有41%)。当询问患者看脊椎按摩师是否改变了他们对服用止痛药的信念或行为时,两组之间没有统计学差异。在脊椎按摩护理是否适合作为背痛治疗方法这一问题上,两组之间存在显著差异(接受DC治疗的患者中有79%,接受PCP治疗的患者中有45%)。在接受PCP治疗的患者中有7%,接受DC治疗的患者中有23%同意DC将是他们因一般健康需求而希望就诊的首选医疗服务提供者。
在这个患者样本中,患者对因背痛接受的脊椎按摩护理满意度很高。患者群体在背痛治疗偏好方面存在差异。我们的结果表明,患者报告因背痛看DC并没有改变他们对其内科PCP提供的处方药治疗的信念或行为。