Henderson Lisa, Devine Katy, Weighall Anna, Gaskell Gareth
Department of Psychology.
School of Psychology, University of Leeds.
Dev Psychol. 2015 Mar;51(3):406-17. doi: 10.1037/a0038786. Epub 2015 Feb 2.
Previous studies using direct forms of vocabulary instruction have shown that newly learned words are integrated with existing lexical knowledge only after off-line consolidation (as measured by competition between new and existing words during spoken word recognition). However, the bulk of vocabulary acquisition during childhood occurs through incidental exposure to verbal material; hence, the role of consolidation may be different or limited when learning is less explicit. To address this, 40 children (ages 7-10 years) and 33 adults listened to a fictitious story that contained 12 novel words (e.g., "daffodat"). Lexical integration was measured by comparing pause detection latencies to existing competitors (e.g., "daffo_dil") and control words for which no new competitor had been encountered. Pause detection latencies were slower for existing competitors than control words (signifying increased lexical competition) 24 hr after exposure to the novel words but not immediately. Both groups recalled significantly more novel words when tested 24 hr after hearing the story than immediately. It is important that children with better expressive vocabulary knowledge showed larger consolidation effects for the novel words, both in terms of strengthening of explicit knowledge and their integration with existing knowledge. Off-line consolidation is therefore required for the integration of new and established knowledge when words are learned under relatively naturalistic conditions. Furthermore, a richer body of established vocabulary knowledge may facilitate (or benefit from) swift lexical integration of new vocabulary.
以往使用直接词汇教学形式的研究表明,新学的单词只有在离线巩固之后才会与现有的词汇知识整合(通过口语单词识别过程中新词与现有词之间的竞争来衡量)。然而,儿童时期的大量词汇习得是通过偶然接触语言材料实现的;因此,当学习不太明确时,巩固的作用可能会有所不同或受到限制。为了解决这个问题,40名儿童(7至10岁)和33名成年人听了一个包含12个新单词(如“daffodat”)的虚构故事。通过比较对现有竞争词(如“daffo_dil”)和未遇到新竞争词的控制词的停顿检测潜伏期来测量词汇整合。接触新单词24小时后,现有竞争词的停顿检测潜伏期比控制词慢(表明词汇竞争增加),但立即测试时并非如此。两组在听完故事24小时后测试时比立即测试时回忆起的新单词明显更多。重要的是,具有更好表达性词汇知识的儿童对新单词表现出更大的巩固效果,无论是在明确知识的强化方面,还是在与现有知识的整合方面。因此,当在相对自然的条件下学习单词时,离线巩固对于新知识与已建立知识的整合是必要的。此外,更丰富的已建立词汇知识体系可能有助于(或受益于)新词汇的快速词汇整合。