Moverley Anna, Coates Laura, Marzo-Ortega Helena, Waxman Robin, Torgerson David, Cocks Kim, Watson Judith, Helliwell Philip S
York Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, York, North Yorkshire, UK.
Clin Rheumatol. 2015 Aug;34(8):1407-12. doi: 10.1007/s10067-015-2886-1. Epub 2015 Feb 3.
TNF therapy is effective for all aspects of psoriatic disease, but these drugs are costly and the long-term effects are unknown. Further, methotrexate causes concern with long-term adverse events. The purpose of this pilot study was to test the feasibility of drug withdrawal from patients with psoriatic arthritis, in stable low disease state. We examined the availability of patients, their willingness to participate, study procedures, and the proportion of patients in the withdrawal arm who relapsed during the study. Low disease state was defined by minimal disease activity criteria (MDA), and relapse by failure to achieve these criteria. Patients in the withdrawal group underwent a phased withdrawal of medication where the last treatment added was the first withdrawn. Assessments were monthly for 3 months before study exit. Seventy-two patients were invited to participate, of which 57 were found to be eligible. Twenty-six (36.1 %) subsequently attended the screening visit but 9 failed eligibility criteria so that 17 patients (29.8 % of the 57 eligible patients, 95 % confidence interval (CI) 18.4, 43.4 %) were randomised at a ratio of 2:1 in favour of the withdrawal arm (11 withdrawals, 6 standard care). Six patients experienced a flare, all of whom were in the withdrawal arm (relapse rate 54.6 %, 95 % CI 23.4, 83.3 %). Four of the flares were apparent from visit 3 (8 weeks after starting withdrawal). Given the high relapse rate, an alternative trial design of partial treatment withdrawal, possibly including a patient preference arm, is recommended.
肿瘤坏死因子(TNF)治疗对银屑病的各个方面均有效,但这些药物价格昂贵且长期效果未知。此外,甲氨蝶呤会引发对长期不良事件的担忧。这项初步研究的目的是测试在疾病处于稳定低水平状态的银屑病关节炎患者中停药的可行性。我们研究了患者的可及性、参与意愿、研究程序以及停药组患者在研究期间复发的比例。低疾病状态由最小疾病活动标准(MDA)定义,复发则定义为未达到这些标准。停药组的患者接受了分阶段停药,其中最后添加的治疗药物最先停用。在研究结束前的3个月内每月进行评估。邀请了72名患者参与,其中57名被认为符合条件。随后有26名(36.1%)患者参加了筛查访视,但9名未通过资格标准,因此17名患者(占57名符合条件患者的29.8%,95%置信区间(CI)为18.4, 43.4%)以2:1的比例随机分组,倾向于停药组(11名停药,6名接受标准治疗)。6名患者病情复发,所有复发患者均在停药组(复发率54.6%,95% CI为23.4, 83.3%)。其中4名患者在第3次访视(开始停药8周后)时病情明显复发。鉴于高复发率,建议采用部分治疗停药的替代试验设计,可能包括患者偏好组。