Al-Jughiman Mohammed K, Al-Omair Maryam A, Van Arsdell Glen S, Morell Victor O, Jacobs Marshall L
University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada,
Pediatr Cardiol. 2015 Jun;36(5):896-905. doi: 10.1007/s00246-015-1092-x. Epub 2015 Feb 3.
Several procedures have been introduced to manage this complex congenital heart malformation. It is not clear that any one approach is best for all patients. Decision-making for a given patient may be influenced by multiple patient factors. There is little doubt that surgeon and institutional experience and preference also play a role. We have focused our survey on three procedures, i.e., the Rastelli, Nikaidoh (aortic root translocation), and réparation à l'étageventriculaire (REV) procedures. The questionnaire was directed to all Congenital Heart Surgeon Society member surgeons. A total of 61 clinical practitioners responded to our survey. Of them, 45 (73.8 %) were staff congenital heart surgeons, 11 (18 %) were staff pediatric cardiologists, 1 (1.6 %) was a staff adult congenital cardiologist, 1 (1.6 %) was a fellow pediatric cardiologist, 2 (3.3 %) were fellow or resident congenital heart surgeons, and 1 (1.6 %) was a nurse practitioner. Most respondents believe that the Rastelli procedure should be considered the first option (n = 28, 45.9 %), while 24 (39.3 %) respondents believe that the Nikaidoh procedure should be considered the first option. Asked "To which surgeon do you prefer to refer your patient" (one who will perform Rastelli, Nikaidoh, or REV), all staff cardiologists (n = 12, 100 %) responded "doesn't matter." This survey revealed a wide diversity among clinical practitioners in terms of management of patients with TGA/VSD/LVOTO and preferred surgical approaches. A multi-institutional study of surgical management of TGA/VSD/LVOTO may help to define principles for optimal matching of procedures to patients.
已经引入了几种方法来处理这种复杂的先天性心脏畸形。目前尚不清楚哪种方法对所有患者都是最佳的。针对特定患者的决策可能会受到多种患者因素的影响。毫无疑问,外科医生和机构的经验及偏好也起到一定作用。我们的调查集中在三种手术方法上,即Rastelli手术、Nikaidoh手术(主动脉根部移位术)和心室修复手术(REV手术)。调查问卷面向先天性心脏外科医生协会的所有成员外科医生。共有61名临床从业者回复了我们的调查。其中,45名(73.8%)是先天性心脏病专科外科医生,11名(18%)是儿科心脏病专科医生,1名(1.6%)是成人先天性心脏病专科医生,1名(1.6%)是儿科心脏病专科进修医生,2名(3.3%)是先天性心脏病专科进修医生或住院医生,1名(1.6%)是执业护士。大多数受访者认为Rastelli手术应被视为首选(n = 28,45.9%),而24名(39.3%)受访者认为Nikaidoh手术应被视为首选。当被问及“你更愿意将患者推荐给哪位外科医生”(进行Rastelli手术、Nikaidoh手术或REV手术的医生)时,所有心脏病专科医生(n = 12,100%)回答“无所谓”。这项调查显示,在完全性大动脉转位/室间隔缺损/左心室流出道梗阻患者的治疗管理及首选手术方法方面,临床从业者之间存在很大差异。一项关于完全性大动脉转位/室间隔缺损/左心室流出道梗阻手术治疗管理的多机构研究可能有助于确定手术方法与患者最佳匹配的原则。