Li Yu-Bing, Zhou Xue-Zhong, Zhang Run-Shun, Wang Ying-Hui, Peng Yonghong, Hu Jing-Qing, Xie Qi, Xue Yan-Xing, Xu Li-Li, Liu Xiao-Fang, Liu Bao-Yan
School of Computer and Information Technology and Beijing Key Lab of Traffic Data Analysis and Mining, Beijing Jiaotong University, Beijing 100044, China.
Guanganmen Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medicine Sciences, Beijing 100053, China.
Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2015;2015:270450. doi: 10.1155/2015/270450. Epub 2015 Jan 11.
Background. Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) is an individualized medicine by observing the symptoms and signs (symptoms in brief) of patients. We aim to extract the meaningful herb-symptom relationships from large scale TCM clinical data. Methods. To investigate the correlations between symptoms and herbs held for patients, we use four clinical data sets collected from TCM outpatient clinical settings and calculate the similarities between patient pairs in terms of the herb constituents of their prescriptions and their manifesting symptoms by cosine measure. To address the large-scale multiple testing problems for the detection of herb-symptom associations and the dependence between herbs involving similar efficacies, we propose a network-based correlation analysis (NetCorrA) method to detect the herb-symptom associations. Results. The results show that there are strong positive correlations between symptom similarity and herb similarity, which indicates that herb-symptom correspondence is a clinical principle adhered to by most TCM physicians. Furthermore, the NetCorrA method obtains meaningful herb-symptom associations and performs better than the chi-square correlation method by filtering the false positive associations. Conclusions. Symptoms play significant roles for the prescriptions of herb treatment. The herb-symptom correspondence principle indicates that clinical phenotypic targets (i.e., symptoms) of herbs exist and would be valuable for further investigations.
背景。中医是通过观察患者的症状和体征(简称症状)进行个体化治疗的医学。我们旨在从大规模中医临床数据中提取有意义的药症关系。方法。为了研究患者所服用的药物与症状之间的相关性,我们使用了从中医门诊临床环境收集的四个临床数据集,并通过余弦度量计算患者对在其处方的药物成分和表现出的症状方面的相似性。为了解决检测药症关联时的大规模多重检验问题以及涉及相似功效的药物之间的依赖性,我们提出了一种基于网络的相关性分析(NetCorrA)方法来检测药症关联。结果。结果表明症状相似性与药物相似性之间存在很强的正相关性,这表明药症对应是大多数中医医生遵循的临床原则。此外,NetCorrA方法通过过滤假阳性关联获得了有意义的药症关联,并且比卡方相关性方法表现更好。结论。症状在草药治疗处方中起着重要作用。药症对应原则表明草药的临床表型靶点(即症状)是存在的,并且对于进一步的研究将是有价值的。