Yeh Li-Li, Wells Bill, Stackhouse Joy, Szczerbinski Marcin
Department of Audiology and Speech-Language Pathology, Mackay Medical College , New Taipei City , Taiwan .
Clin Linguist Phon. 2015 Apr;29(4):266-75. doi: 10.3109/02699206.2014.1003328. Epub 2015 Feb 4.
Two competing approaches to the analysis of the phonological structure of Mandarin syllables have been put forward. The first and more traditional approach is that a syllable can be segmented into initial consonant, medial glide, nucleus plus coda and tone. The second approach does not distinguish the non-compulsory medial glide as an independent element. To compare and evaluate these two different approaches, the development of phoneme-level awareness was investigated in 67 Mandarin-speaking children in Year 1 of school (mean age: 6;9) and Year 5 (mean age: 10;1). Results showed that at school entry some children were sensitive to glides and to a lesser extent to codas; their number increased by Year 5. This suggests that spoken language experience is enough for some children to acquire the representation of glides and codas; this is consistent with the traditional model of the Mandarin syllable, with both glides and codas as independent elements. However, the children's task performance was generally rather poor, even in Year 5, suggesting that development of phonemic sensitivity in Mandarin speaking children is not substantially improved by increased literacy experience.
针对汉语普通话音节的音系结构分析,已经提出了两种相互竞争的方法。第一种也是更为传统的方法是,一个音节可以被切分为声母、介音、韵腹加韵尾和声调。第二种方法并不将非强制性的介音视为一个独立的元素。为了比较和评估这两种不同的方法,对67名一年级(平均年龄:6岁9个月)和五年级(平均年龄:10岁1个月)说普通话的儿童的音素层级意识发展情况进行了研究。结果显示,在刚入学时,一些儿童对介音敏感,对韵尾的敏感程度稍低;到五年级时,这类儿童的数量有所增加。这表明,对于一些儿童来说,口语经验足以让他们习得介音和韵尾的表征;这与将介音和韵尾都视为独立元素的传统普通话音节模型是一致的。然而,即使在五年级,儿童的任务表现总体上也相当差,这表明增加读写经验并没有显著提高说普通话儿童的音素敏感性发展。