Wright Naomi J, Zani Augusto, Ade-Ajayi Niyi
Department of Paediatric Surgery, Kings College Hospital, London, United Kingdom.
Afr J Paediatr Surg. 2015 Jan-Mar;12(1):1-6. doi: 10.4103/0189-6725.150924.
The aim was to compare gastroschisis (GS) epidemiology, management and outcome in low-income countries (LIC) in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) with middle- (MIC) and high-income countries (HIC).
A 10-question survey was administered at the 2012 Pan-African Paediatric Surgery Association Congress. RESULTS are presented as median (range); differences were analysed using contingency tests.
A total of 82 delegates (28 countries [66 institutions]) were divided into LIC (n = 11), MIC (n = 6) and HIC (n = 11). In LIC, there were fewer surgeons and more patients. LIC reported 22 cases (1-184) GS/institution/year, compared to 12 cases (3-23)/institution/year in MICs and 15 cases (1-100)/institution/year in HICs. Antenatal screening was less readily available in LIC. Access to parenteral nutrition and neonatal intensive care in LIC was 36% and 19%, compared to 100% in HIC. Primary closure rates were similar in LIC and HIC at 58% and 54%, respectively; however, the majority of staged closure utilised custom silos in LIC and preformed silos in HIC. In LIC, mortality was reported as >75% by 61% delegates and 50-75% by 33%, compared to <25% by 100% of HIC delegates (P < 0.0001).
Gastroschisis is a problem encountered by surgeons in SSA. Mortality is high and resources in many centres inadequate. We propose the implementation of a combined epidemiological research, service delivery training and resource provision programme to help improve our understanding of GS in SSA whilst attempting to improve outcome.
目的是比较撒哈拉以南非洲(SSA)的低收入国家(LIC)与中等收入国家(MIC)和高收入国家(HIC)的腹裂(GS)流行病学、管理及治疗结果。
在2012年泛非儿科学会外科大会上进行了一项包含10个问题的调查。结果以中位数(范围)呈现;差异采用列联检验进行分析。
共有82名代表(来自28个国家[66个机构])被分为LIC组(n = 11)、MIC组(n = 6)和HIC组(n = 11)。在LIC,外科医生较少而患者较多。LIC报告每个机构每年有22例(1 - 184例)GS,相比之下,MIC为每个机构每年12例(3 - 23例),HIC为每个机构每年15例(1 - 100例)。LIC中产前筛查较难获得。LIC中肠外营养和新生儿重症监护的可及率分别为36%和19%,而HIC为100%。LIC和HIC的一期闭合率相似,分别为58%和54%;然而,LIC中大多数分期闭合使用定制的储袋,而HIC使用预制储袋。在LIC,61%的代表报告死亡率>75%,33%报告死亡率为50 - 75%,相比之下,100%的HIC代表报告死亡率<25%(P < 0.0001)。
腹裂是SSA外科医生面临的一个问题。死亡率高且许多中心资源不足。我们建议实施一项综合的流行病学研究、服务提供培训和资源供应计划,以帮助提高我们对SSA地区腹裂的认识,同时试图改善治疗结果。