Epstein A S, Shuk E, O'Reilly E M, Gary K A, Volandes A E
Department of Medicine, Gastrointestinal Medical Oncology Service, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, USA.
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, USA.
Psychooncology. 2015 Dec;24(12):1767-73. doi: 10.1002/pon.3786. Epub 2015 Feb 23.
Most cancer patients desire information about care options at the end of life, including cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR). Communicating such care options can be challenging and is part of advance care planning (ACP). Our prior studies with video educational media produced data on patients' categoric preferences (yes/no/unsure) for CPR; however, the thematic underpinnings of these educated preferences in patients treated for advanced cancer aren't well known.
Qualitative thematic content analysis of participants' responses in a randomized trial of an educational video (V) or narrative (N) about CPR in patients with advanced gastrointestinal cancers. Responses were independently coded and categorized for thematic content by two reviewers.
Of 54 study participants, 26 total (41% of V arm, 56% of N arm) articulated questions, comments, or both. Reviewer analyses demonstrated thematic consensus and resulted in seven distinct themes listed in decreasing order of prevalence: (a) ACP should be started early; (b) educational information about CPR affirmed participants' existing beliefs/knowledge/values about advanced illness; (c) participants were apprehensive about ACP but wanted to discuss it; (d) gaps in knowledge about ACP emerged; (e) CPR information was helpful/acceptable; (f) physicians should be involved in ACP; and (g) medical questions about critical illness arose.
Findings identified that while sometimes difficult to discuss, advance care planning is desired, deemed helpful, and ideally begun early by clinicians, and that video education is an appropriate and affirming initiator of discussions. These themes are incorporated into our ongoing research on cancer patient-specific values and education about care options.
大多数癌症患者希望了解临终时的护理选择信息,包括心肺复苏(CPR)。传达此类护理选择可能具有挑战性,并且是预先护理计划(ACP)的一部分。我们之前对视频教育媒体的研究得出了患者对心肺复苏的分类偏好(是/否/不确定)数据;然而,在接受晚期癌症治疗的患者中,这些经过教育的偏好背后的主题基础尚不清楚。
对晚期胃肠道癌症患者关于心肺复苏的教育视频(V)或叙述(N)的随机试验中参与者的回答进行定性主题内容分析。两名评审员对回答进行独立编码并按主题内容分类。
在54名研究参与者中,共有26名(视频组的41%,叙述组的56%)表达了问题、评论或两者皆有。评审员分析显示出主题共识,并得出了七个不同的主题,按出现频率从高到低排列如下:(a)应尽早开始预先护理计划;(b)关于心肺复苏的教育信息证实了参与者对晚期疾病的现有信念/知识/价值观;(c)参与者对预先护理计划感到担忧,但希望进行讨论;(d)出现了关于预先护理计划的知识差距;(e)心肺复苏信息是有帮助的/可接受的;(f)医生应参与预先护理计划;(g)出现了关于危重病的医学问题。
研究结果表明,虽然有时难以讨论,但预先护理计划是患者所期望的,被认为是有帮助的,并且临床医生最好尽早开始,而且视频教育是讨论的合适且能起到肯定作用的发起方式。这些主题已纳入我们正在进行的关于癌症患者特定价值观和护理选择教育的研究中。