Curtis Jonathan
College of Medicine, University of Swansea, Singleton Park, Swansea SA2 8PP, UK.
J Public Health (Oxf). 2016 Mar;38(1):106-14. doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdv014. Epub 2015 Feb 25.
Tuberculosis prevalence is generally low in industrialized countries, but many cities now operate surveillance programmes to actively screen for tuberculosis in known risk groups including homeless people. While several studies have reported on individual screening programmes, this study is the first known systematic review specifically looking at chest x-ray screening programmes for tuberculosis in homeless populations.
Systematic review of relevant studies published in the last 20 years using the PRISMA checklist.
Fourteen studies were reviewed: 12 cross-sectional studies, 1 retrospective cohort study and 1 'data-linkage' study. The studies were heterogenous in terms of the objectives, measured outcomes and methodological quality. Active tuberculosis prevalence was found to be higher in homeless populations and screening programmes appear to identify tuberculosis earlier, reduce prevalence and transmission, and increase treatment compliance.
Active x-ray surveillance programmes in homeless communities appear to be cost-effective in reducing prevalence within the homeless population particularly in related strains and may have some benefits over passive finding. While there is a need for high-quality research to further assess the impact of these programmes, this study has outlined the benefits and limitations of existing programmes and included recommendations to achieve maximum coverage, uptake and cost-benefit.
在工业化国家,结核病的患病率普遍较低,但现在许多城市开展了监测项目,以积极筛查包括无家可归者在内的已知风险群体中的结核病。虽然已有多项研究报道了个别筛查项目,但本研究是首次专门针对无家可归人群胸部X线筛查结核病项目的系统评价。
使用PRISMA清单对过去二十年发表的相关研究进行系统评价。
共纳入14项研究:12项横断面研究、1项回顾性队列研究和1项“数据关联”研究。这些研究在目标、测量结果和方法学质量方面存在异质性。发现无家可归人群中活动性结核病的患病率较高,筛查项目似乎能更早地发现结核病,降低患病率和传播率,并提高治疗依从性。
在无家可归社区开展的活动性X线监测项目在降低无家可归人群中的患病率方面似乎具有成本效益,特别是在相关菌株方面,并且可能比被动发现有一些优势。虽然需要高质量的研究来进一步评估这些项目的影响,但本研究概述了现有项目的益处和局限性,并提出了实现最大覆盖范围、接受率和成本效益的建议。