Barnes R D, Ivezaj V
Department of Psychiatry, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut, USA.
Obes Rev. 2015 Apr;16(4):304-18. doi: 10.1111/obr.12264. Epub 2015 Mar 5.
Motivational interviewing (MI) is a client-centred method of intervention focused on enhancing intrinsic motivation and behaviour change. A previous review of the literature and meta-analyses support the effectiveness of MI for weight loss. None of these studies, however, focused on the bourgeoning literature examining MI for weight loss among adults within primary care settings, which confers unique barriers to providing weight loss treatment. Further, the current review includes 19 studies not included in previous reviews or meta-analyses. We conducted a comprehensive review of PubMed, MI review papers, and citations from relevant papers. A total of 24 adult randomized controlled trials were identified. MI interventions typically were provided individually by a range of clinicians and compared with usual care. Few studies provided adequate information regarding MI treatment fidelity. Nine studies (37.5%) reported significant weight loss at post-treatment assessment for the MI condition compared with control groups. Thirteen studies (54.2%) reported MI patients achieving at least 5% loss of initial body weight. There is potential for MI to help primary care patients lose weight. Conclusions, however, must be drawn cautiously as more than half of the reviewed studies showed no significant weight loss compared with usual care and few reported MI treatment fidelity.
动机性访谈(MI)是一种以客户为中心的干预方法,专注于增强内在动机和行为改变。先前的文献综述和荟萃分析支持了MI对减肥的有效性。然而,这些研究均未关注在初级保健环境中针对成年人减肥的MI的新兴文献,而这为提供减肥治疗带来了独特的障碍。此外,本次综述纳入了19项先前综述或荟萃分析中未包含的研究。我们对PubMed、MI综述论文以及相关论文的参考文献进行了全面检索。共识别出24项成人随机对照试验。MI干预通常由一系列临床医生单独提供,并与常规护理进行比较。很少有研究提供关于MI治疗保真度的充分信息。9项研究(37.5%)报告,与对照组相比,MI组在治疗后评估时体重显著减轻。13项研究(54.2%)报告,MI组患者初始体重减轻至少5%。MI有可能帮助初级保健患者减肥。然而,由于超过一半的综述研究表明与常规护理相比体重没有显著减轻,且很少有研究报告MI治疗保真度,因此得出结论时必须谨慎。