Bulut Olcay Cem, Wallner Frank, Plinkert Peter K, Prochnow Sebastian, Kuhnt Christoph, Baumann Ingo
Rhinology. 2015 Mar;53(1):54-8. doi: 10.4193/Rhino14.008.
Quality of life measurements in septorhinoplasty patients so far have taken place only to a small extent. The aim of the present study was a prospective measurement of disease-specific quality of life with a newly developed and validated instrument, the Functional Rhinoplasty Outcome Inventory 17 (FROI-17).
The patients completed the FROI-17 and the Rhinoplasty Outcome Evaluation (ROE) as disease-specific instruments preoperatively as well as 12 months postoperatively. As a general instrument, the Short Form 36 Health Survey (SF-36) was used. Furthermore, additional general questions were answered at both time points.
Out of the 103 patients, 69 patients (32 men, 37 women) responded after 12 months (response rate 67%). Thirteen patients (18%) were not satisfied with the result of surgery. However, all scales of FROI-17 and also ROE showed a significant postoperative improvement of subjective assessments by the patients. In the SF-36, this was true in 2 out of 8 scales (mental health and role-functioning physical). Furthermore, we found significant correlations between the FROI-17 and the SF-36 scales but not between the ROE and the SF-36 scales.
The disease-specific quality of life was significantly improved by septorhinoplasty. FROI-17 scales detect more functional aspects compared with the ROE thus establishing significant correlations with general quality of life measured by SF-36. The application of both FROI-17 and ROE in future clinical trials in septorhinoplasty patients is recommended.
迄今为止,在鼻中隔成形术患者中进行生活质量测量的情况还比较少见。本研究的目的是使用一种新开发并经过验证的工具——功能性鼻整形术结果量表17(FROI - 17),对特定疾病的生活质量进行前瞻性测量。
患者在术前以及术后12个月完成FROI - 17和鼻整形术结果评估(ROE)这两种特定疾病的量表。作为通用量表,使用了简短健康调查问卷36(SF - 36)。此外,在两个时间点都回答了其他一般性问题。
103例患者中,69例患者(32例男性,37例女性)在12个月后做出了回应(回应率67%)。13例患者(18%)对手术结果不满意。然而,FROI - 17的所有量表以及ROE均显示患者的主观评估在术后有显著改善。在SF - 36中,8个量表中有2个(心理健康和身体角色功能)是这样。此外,我们发现FROI - 17与SF - 36量表之间存在显著相关性,但ROE与SF - 36量表之间不存在显著相关性。
鼻中隔成形术使特定疾病的生活质量得到显著改善。与ROE相比,FROI - 17量表能检测到更多功能方面的内容,并因此与通过SF - 36测量的总体生活质量建立了显著相关性。建议在未来鼻中隔成形术患者的临床试验中同时应用FROI - 17和ROE。