Warneken Felix, Orlins Emily
Department of Psychology, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, USA.
Br J Dev Psychol. 2015 Sep;33(3):259-70. doi: 10.1111/bjdp.12083. Epub 2015 Mar 15.
We investigated whether children tell white lies simply out of politeness or as a means to improve another person's mood. A first experimental phase probed children's individual insight to use white lies when prosocial behaviour was called for. We compared a situation in which a person had expressed sadness about her artwork and the goal was to make her feel better (Sad condition) with a situation in which a person was indifferent about her work (Neutral condition). Children at 7 years and older were more likely to tell a white lie than the blunt truth in the Sad over the Neutral condition. Five-year-olds showed only a trend. A second phase tested whether children selectively use white lie telling after it was modelled by an adult. Results showed that after modelling, children from all age groups were significantly more likely to use white lies in the Sad condition than in the Neutral condition. Taken together, these results show that children are attentive to another person's affective states when choosing whether to tell a white lie or tell the truth. We discuss the emergence of this behaviour in relation to children's developing social cognition and the increasing sophistication of children's prosocial behaviour.
我们研究了儿童说善意谎言仅仅是出于礼貌,还是作为改善他人情绪的一种方式。第一个实验阶段探究了在需要亲社会行为时,儿童个人使用善意谎言的洞察力。我们将一个人对自己的艺术作品表示悲伤且目标是让她感觉更好的情境(悲伤情境)与一个人对自己的作品漠不关心的情境(中性情境)进行了比较。在悲伤情境中,7岁及以上的儿童比起在中性情境中更有可能说善意谎言而非直言真相。5岁儿童仅表现出一种趋势。第二阶段测试了在成人示范之后,儿童是否会选择性地使用善意谎言。结果显示,在示范之后,所有年龄组的儿童在悲伤情境中比在中性情境中更有可能使用善意谎言。综合来看,这些结果表明,儿童在选择是说善意谎言还是说实话时,会关注他人的情感状态。我们讨论了这种行为的出现与儿童不断发展的社会认知以及儿童亲社会行为日益复杂之间的关系。