Sørensen Louise B, Dyssegaard Camilla B, Damsgaard Camilla T, Petersen Rikke A, Dalskov Stine-Mathilde, Hjorth Mads F, Andersen Rikke, Tetens Inge, Ritz Christian, Astrup Arne, Lauritzen Lotte, Michaelsen Kim F, Egelund Niels
Department of Nutrition,Exercise and Sports, Faculty of Science, University of Copenhagen,Rolighedsvej 30,DK-1958Frederiksberg C,Denmark.
Department of Education,Faculty of Arts, Aarhus University,Copenhagen,Denmark.
Br J Nutr. 2015 Apr 28;113(8):1280-91. doi: 10.1017/S0007114515000033. Epub 2015 Mar 20.
It is widely assumed that nutrition can improve school performance in children; however, evidence remains limited and inconclusive. In the present study, we investigated whether serving healthy school meals influenced concentration and school performance of 8- to 11-year-old Danish children. The OPUS (Optimal well-being, development and health for Danish children through a healthy New Nordic Diet) School Meal Study was a cluster-randomised, controlled, cross-over trial comparing a healthy school meal programme with the usual packed lunch from home (control) each for 3 months (NCT 01457794). The d2 test of attention, the Learning Rating Scale (LRS) and standard tests on reading and mathematics proficiency were administered at baseline and at the end of each study period. Intervention effects were evaluated using hierarchical mixed models. The school meal intervention did not influence concentration performance (CP; primary outcome, n 693) or processing speed; however, the decrease in error percentage was 0·18 points smaller (P<0·001) in the intervention period than in the control period (medians: baseline 2·03%; intervention 1·46%; control 1·37%). In contrast, the intervention increased reading speed (0·7 sentence, P=0·009) and the number of correct sentences (1·8 sentences, P<0·001), which corresponded to 11 and 25%, respectively, of the effect of one school year. The percentage of correct sentences also improved (P<0·001), indicating that the number correct improved relatively more than reading speed. There was no effect on overall math performance or outcomes from the LRS. In conclusion, school meals did not affect CP, but improved reading performance, which is a complex cognitive activity that involves inference, and increased errors related to impulsivity and inattention. These findings are worth examining in future trials.
人们普遍认为营养可以提高儿童的学习成绩;然而,相关证据仍然有限且尚无定论。在本研究中,我们调查了提供健康的学校餐食是否会影响8至11岁丹麦儿童的注意力和学习成绩。OPUS(通过健康的新北欧饮食实现丹麦儿童的最佳幸福、发展和健康)学校餐食研究是一项整群随机对照交叉试验,比较了一项健康学校餐食计划与通常的家庭自带午餐(对照),各为期3个月(NCT 01457794)。在基线期和每个研究期结束时,进行了注意力的d2测试、学习评定量表(LRS)以及阅读和数学能力的标准测试。使用分层混合模型评估干预效果。学校餐食干预并未影响注意力表现(CP;主要结局,n = 693)或处理速度;然而,干预期内错误百分比的下降幅度比对照期小0.18个百分点(P<0.001)(中位数:基线期2.03%;干预期1.46%;对照期1.37%)。相比之下,干预提高了阅读速度(0.7个句子,P = 0.009)和正确句子的数量(1.8个句子,P<0.001),分别相当于一学年效果的11%和25%。正确句子的百分比也有所提高(P<0.001),表明正确数量的提高相对阅读速度更为明显。对整体数学成绩或LRS的结果没有影响。总之,学校餐食并未影响注意力表现,但提高了阅读成绩,阅读是一项涉及推理的复杂认知活动,同时与冲动性和注意力不集中相关的错误有所增加。这些发现值得在未来的试验中进一步研究。