Van den Brom R, Santman-Berends I, Luttikholt S, Moll L, Van Engelen E, Vellema P
Department of Small Ruminant Health, GD Animal Health, 7400 AA Deventer, the Netherlands.
Department of Research and Development, GD Animal Health, 7400 AA Deventer, the Netherlands.
J Dairy Sci. 2015 Jun;98(6):3814-25. doi: 10.3168/jds.2014-9029. Epub 2015 Mar 18.
In the period from 2005 to 2009, Coxiella burnetii was a cause of abortion waves at 28 dairy goat farms and 2 dairy sheep farms in the Netherlands. Two years after the first abortion waves, a large human Q fever outbreak started mainly in the same region, and aborting small ruminants were regarded as most probable source. To distinguish between infected and noninfected herds, a surveillance program started in October 2009, based on PCR testing of bulk tank milk (BTM) samples, which had never been described before. The aim of this study was to analyze the effectiveness of this surveillance program and to evaluate both the effect of culling of pregnant dairy goats on positive farms and of vaccination on BTM results. Bulk tank milk samples were tested for C. burnetii DNA using a real-time PCR, and results were analyzed in relation to vaccination, culling, and notifiable (officially reported to government) C. burnetii abortion records. In spring and autumn, BTM samples were also tested for antibodies using an ELISA, and results were evaluated in relation to the compulsory vaccination campaign. Between October 2009 and April 2014, 1,660 (5.6%) out of 29,875 BTM samples from 401 dairy goat farms tested positive for C. burnetii DNA. The percentage of positive samples dropped from 20.5% in 2009 to 0.3% in 2014. In a multivariable model, significantly higher odds of being PCR positive in the BTM surveillance program were found in farms of which all pregnant dairy goats were culled. Additionally, the risk for C. burnetii BTM PCR positivity significantly decreased after multiple vaccinations. Bulk tank milk ELISA results were significantly higher after vaccination than before. The ELISA results were higher after multiple vaccinations compared with a single vaccination, and ELISA results on officially declared infected farms were significantly higher compared with noninfected farms. In conclusion, BTM surveillance is an effective and useful tool to detect C. burnetii shedding dairy goat herds and to monitor a Q fever outbreak, and thus the effect of implemented measures.
2005年至2009年期间,伯氏考克斯体是荷兰28个奶山羊场和2个奶绵羊场流产潮的病因。首次流产潮发生两年后,一场大规模的人类Q热疫情主要在同一地区爆发,流产的小反刍动物被视为最可能的传染源。为区分感染和未感染的畜群,2009年10月启动了一项监测计划,该计划基于对储奶罐牛奶(BTM)样本进行PCR检测,这在此前从未有过描述。本研究的目的是分析该监测计划的有效性,并评估对阳性农场怀孕奶山羊进行扑杀以及疫苗接种对BTM检测结果的影响。使用实时PCR对储奶罐牛奶样本检测伯氏考克斯体DNA,并结合疫苗接种、扑杀以及法定(官方上报给政府)的伯氏考克斯体流产记录对结果进行分析。在春季和秋季,还使用ELISA对BTM样本检测抗体,并结合强制疫苗接种活动评估结果。2009年10月至2014年4月期间,来自401个奶山羊场的29,875份BTM样本中有1,660份(5.6%)伯氏考克斯体DNA检测呈阳性。阳性样本百分比从2009年的20.5%降至2014年的0.3%。在多变量模型中,发现所有怀孕奶山羊均被扑杀的农场在BTM监测计划中PCR呈阳性的几率显著更高。此外,多次接种疫苗后,伯氏考克斯体BTM PCR阳性风险显著降低。接种疫苗后储奶罐牛奶ELISA结果显著高于接种前。多次接种后的ELISA结果高于单次接种,官方宣布感染农场的ELISA结果显著高于未感染农场。总之,BTM监测是检测排伯氏考克斯体奶山羊群和监测Q热疫情以及所采取措施效果的有效且有用的工具。