He Guang Ping
School of Physics and Engineering, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou 510275, China.
Sci Rep. 2015 Mar 23;5:9398. doi: 10.1038/srep09398.
Cheat sensitive quantum bit commitment (CSQBC) loosens the security requirement of quantum bit commitment (QBC), so that the existing impossibility proofs of unconditionally secure QBC can be evaded. But here we analyze the common features in all existing CSQBC protocols, and show that in any CSQBC having these features, the receiver can always learn a non-trivial amount of information on the sender's committed bit before it is unveiled, while his cheating can pass the security check with a probability not less than 50%. The sender's cheating is also studied. The optimal CSQBC protocols that can minimize the sum of the cheating probabilities of both parties are found to be trivial, as they are practically useless. We also discuss the possibility of building a fair protocol in which both parties can cheat with equal probabilities.
欺骗敏感量子比特承诺(CSQBC)放宽了量子比特承诺(QBC)的安全要求,从而可以规避现有的无条件安全QBC的不可能性证明。但在这里,我们分析了所有现有CSQBC协议中的共同特征,并表明在任何具有这些特征的CSQBC中,接收者在发送者承诺的比特被揭示之前,总能了解到关于该比特的大量非平凡信息,而其欺骗行为能够以不低于50%的概率通过安全检查。我们还研究了发送者的欺骗行为。结果发现,能够使双方欺骗概率之和最小化的最优CSQBC协议是平凡的,因为它们实际上毫无用处。我们还讨论了构建一个公平协议的可能性,在该协议中双方能够以相等的概率进行欺骗。