Lee Keumho, Hur Yera
Department of Medical Education, Konyang University College of Medicine, Daejeon, Korea.
Korean J Med Educ. 2012 Dec;24(4):339-46. doi: 10.3946/kjme.2012.24.4.339. Epub 2012 Dec 31.
Evaluating the professional attributes of medical students is critical, because medical professionalism is an essential quality of a good doctor. But, few studies have examined the tools for assessing such attributes. This study analyzed factors of medical professionalism in medical students to develop standards that can assess medical professional attributes.
A total of 1,508 medical students in Korean medical schools or colleges answered a self-assessment survey of medical professionalism elements from 2005 to 2012 that we developed. The survey consisted of core 31 attributes on a 5-point Likert scale. Factor analysis was performed using SPSS version 20.0 and AMOS version 20.0.
Exploratory factor analysis revealed six factors with total variance of 59.56%. The factors were termed 'empathy and accountability,' 'self-development skills,' 'academic competence,' 'interpersonal skills,' 'high intelligence,' and 'attitude towards oneself and life.' These factors showed statistically significant correlation (0.310~0.663). From the confirmatory factor analysis a six-factor model were appropriate (CFI=0.873, TLI=0.853, RMSEA=0.065). Cronbach-alpha of six factors ranged from 0.718 to 0.864.
Good doctors need to have not only appropriate standards of medical knowledge but also skills to understand and communicate well with patients, as well as self-management skills, which should not be overlooked in the medical education curriculum. By optimizing the results of this study, a more refined assessment tool of professionalism can be exploited.
评估医学生的专业属性至关重要,因为医学专业素养是一名优秀医生的基本品质。但是,很少有研究考察评估此类属性的工具。本研究分析了医学生医学专业素养的因素,以制定能够评估医学专业属性的标准。
2005年至2012年期间,韩国医学院校的1508名医学生回答了我们开发的医学专业素养要素的自我评估调查问卷。该调查由31个核心属性组成,采用5点李克特量表。使用SPSS 20.0版和AMOS 20.0版进行因子分析。
探索性因子分析揭示了六个因子,总方差为59.56%。这些因子分别被称为“同理心与责任感”、“自我发展技能”、“学术能力”、“人际技能”、“高智商”以及“对自己和生活的态度”。这些因子显示出统计学上的显著相关性(0.310~0.663)。验证性因子分析表明六因子模型是合适的(CFI=0.873,TLI=0.853,RMSEA=0.065)。六个因子的克朗巴哈系数在0.718至0.864之间。
优秀的医生不仅需要具备适当的医学知识标准,还需要具备理解患者并与患者良好沟通的技能以及自我管理技能,而这些在医学教育课程中不应被忽视。通过优化本研究结果,可以开发出更完善的专业素养评估工具。