D'Antò V, Bucci R, Franchi L, Rongo R, Michelotti A, Martina R
Department of Neuroscience, Reproductive Sciences and Oral Sciences, School of Orthodontics and Temporomandibular disorders, University of Naples "Federico II", Naples, Italy.
Dentist Unit, Department of Pediatric Surgery, "Bambino Gesù" Children Hospital, Rome, Italy.
J Oral Rehabil. 2015 Aug;42(8):624-42. doi: 10.1111/joor.12295. Epub 2015 Mar 31.
This Systematic Review (SR) aims to assess the quality of SRs and Meta-Analyses (MAs) on functional orthopaedic treatment of Class II malocclusion and to summarise and rate the reported effects. Electronic and manual searches were conducted until June 2014. SRs and MAs focusing on the effects of functional orthopaedic treatment of Class II malocclusion in growing patients were included. The methodological quality of the included papers was assessed using the AMSTAR (Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews). The design of the primary studies included in each SR was assessed with Level of Research Design scoring. The evidence of the main outcomes was summarised and rated according to a scale of statements. 14 SRs fulfilled the inclusion criteria. The appliances evaluated were as follows: Activator (2 studies), Twin Block (4 studies), headgear (3 studies), Herbst (2 studies), Jasper Jumper (1 study), Bionator (1 study) and Fränkel-2 (1 study). Four studies reviewed several functional appliances, as a group. The mean AMSTAR score was 6 (ranged 2-10). Six SRs included only controlled clinical trials (CCTs), three SRs included only randomised controlled trials (RCTs), four SRs included both CCTs and RCTs and one SR included also expert opinions. There was some evidence of reduction of the overjet, with different appliances except from headgear; there was some evidence of small maxillary growth restrain with Twin Block and headgear; there was some evidence of elongation of mandibular length, but the clinical relevance of this results is still questionable; there was insufficient evidence to determine an effect on soft tissues.
本系统评价(SR)旨在评估关于Ⅱ类错牙合功能性正畸治疗的系统评价(SR)和Meta分析(MA)的质量,并总结和评价所报道的疗效。截至2014年6月进行了电子检索和手工检索。纳入了关注生长发育期患者Ⅱ类错牙合功能性正畸治疗效果的SR和MA。使用AMSTAR(多种系统评价评估)评估纳入论文的方法学质量。对每个SR中纳入的原始研究设计采用研究设计水平评分进行评估。根据陈述量表总结和评价主要结局的证据。14项SR符合纳入标准。评估的矫治器如下:肌激动器(2项研究)、双阻板矫治器(4项研究)、头帽(3项研究)、Herbst矫治器(2项研究)、Jasper Jumper矫治器(1项研究)、生物调节器(1项研究)和Frankel-2矫治器(1项研究)。4项研究将几种功能性矫治器作为一组进行了综述。AMSTAR平均评分为6分(范围为2 - 10分)。6项SR仅纳入了对照临床试验(CCT),3项SR仅纳入了随机对照试验(RCT),4项SR同时纳入了CCT和RCT,1项SR还纳入了专家意见。有证据表明除头帽外,不同矫治器可使覆盖减小;有证据表明双阻板矫治器和头帽可使上颌生长有一定程度的抑制;有证据表明下颌长度增加,但该结果的临床相关性仍存在疑问;没有足够证据确定对软组织的影响。