Engh C A, Massin P
Department of Orthopaedics, Georgetown University, Washington, D.C.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1989 Dec(249):141-58.
Three hundred forty-three primary hip arthroplasties performed prior to June 1984 were followed for two years, and an additional 204 were followed for five years. Anteroposterior and lateral roentgenograms taken at annual intervals were used for comparison. At two years, 78% of the hips showed roentgenographic signs of stem osseointegration. Seventeen percent were clinically stable but demonstrated reactive lines surrounding the porous surface, indicating lack of bone-ingrowth fixation. Four percent showed late implant migration. Using late migration as an end point, a survivorship analysis of the stem stability was performed. The cumulative survival rate for stable fixation was 94% at five years and 88% at eight years. Among the 143 undersized stems, 17 showed late migration and two failed by stem fracture at six and eight years, giving a cumulative survival rate of 77% at eight years. By contrast, there were no roentgenographic failures among 200 canal-filling stems. Three stems were revised: two for stem fracture and one for loosening with infection. Proximal stress shielding occurred only in bone-ingrowth stems and was slightly progressive. Unstable implants produced progressive intramedullary canal widening. The clinical results were superior when the roentgenograms showed signs of bone-ingrowth fixation. Functional recovery in such cases was equivalent to that for cemented arthroplasty.
对1984年6月之前进行的343例初次髋关节置换术患者进行了两年的随访,另外204例进行了五年的随访。每年拍摄前后位和侧位X线片用于比较。两年时,78%的髋关节显示出假体柄骨整合的X线征象。17%的髋关节临床稳定,但在多孔表面周围出现反应性骨线,表明缺乏骨长入固定。4%的髋关节显示假体晚期移位。以晚期移位作为终点,对假体柄稳定性进行了生存分析。稳定固定的累积生存率在五年时为94%,在八年时为88%。在143例尺寸过小的假体柄中,17例出现晚期移位,2例在六年和八年时因假体柄骨折失败,八年时的累积生存率为77%。相比之下,200例髓腔填充型假体柄中没有X线片显示失败的情况。有3例进行了翻修:2例因假体柄骨折,1例因松动伴感染。近端应力遮挡仅发生在骨长入型假体柄中,且呈轻度进展。不稳定的假体导致髓腔逐渐增宽。当X线片显示骨长入固定征象时,临床结果更佳。此类病例的功能恢复与骨水泥型关节置换术相当。