D'Andrea Giancarlo, Frati Alessandro, Pietrantonio Andrea, Familiari Pietro, Raco Antonino, Ferrante Luigi
S Andrea Hospital, Institute of Neurosurgery, Department of Neuroscience, Mental Health and Sensory Organs University of Rome "La Sapienza", Rome, Italy.
Neurosurgery IRCCS Neuromed, Pozzilli (IS), Italy.
Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 2015 Jun;133:34-9. doi: 10.1016/j.clineuro.2015.03.007. Epub 2015 Mar 16.
INTRODUCTION: The BrainSuite(®) is a highly integrated operating theater designed mainly for brain tumor surgery. The issues concerning its routine use in vascular neurosurgery have not been discussed in literature to date. We report our experience of surgical treatment of cerebral aneurysms in the BrainSuite(®), with a view to evaluating safety, feasibility, advantages, disadvantages, and contraindications. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Retrospectively, we reviewed all the patients affected by ruptured and unruptured aneurysms that underwent craniotomy with clipping between January 2007 and May 2013 and a subsequent minimum 12-month follow up. Intraoperative DWI, MRA, and volumetric MRI were always performed in order to evaluate vessel patency and early ischemic lesions. The usefulness of navigation was also evaluated in terms of loss/gain of time and its effectiveness as a surgical aid to both the localization of small distal aneurysms and the preoperative planning of the clipping strategies to adopt. RESULTS: A total of 105 patients were included in this report. Of these, 39 and 66 were affected, respectively, by ruptured and unruptured aneurysms. The mean age was 56.1 and the male-to-female ratio was 1:2.9. The aneurysms affected, with progressively descending incidence, the MCA, ACoA, ICA bifurcation, PComA, A2, A1-A2, and C6 segment of the ICA in 40 (38.1%), 23 (22%), 15 (14.3%), 7 (6.6%), 7 (6.6%), 7 (6.6%), and 6 (5.8%) cases, respectively. The aneurysms were clipped and completely excluded from blood circulation in all cases and no difficulty was encountered in positioning and fixing the patients' heads, despite the particular head holder of the BrainSuite(®). MRI created no interference or problems in cases of carotid exposure at the neck, while harvesting of the lower-limb saphenous vein was not feasible due to the vicinity of the operating field to the magnet. Intraoperative angiography was never performed since an angiogram is not compatible with the BrainSuite. Intraoperative DWI, MRA, and volumetric MRI proved to be effective tools for post-clipping evaluation of the patency of the parent vessels and their collateral branches as well as of aneurismal occlusion. This was also checked doubly by availing also of intraoperative micro Doppler ultrasonography. Intraoperative DWI also permitted us to evaluate the presence of initial ischemic lesions as possible consequences of both direct arterial occlusion and early vasospasm related to surgical manipulation. Intraoperative navigation of brain aneurysm with 3D-model reconstructions may be of some use to younger surgeons when planning the clipping strategies and localizing the aneurysm particularly in cases, respectively, of large-complex aneurysms where the sac involves collateral branches and small aneurisms affecting both distal ACA and MCA aneurysms. The outcomes for patients, evaluated according to the GOS (Glasgow outcome score), associated significantly with the preoperative HH (Hunt and Hess) scale grading. Patients with high HH scores (IV and V) in particular showed the highest incidence of unfavorable outcome (GOS=1 or 2) CONCLUSIONS: The BrainSuite(®) theater is completely suited to brain aneurysm surgery but only in cases where a combined endovascular approach may be required. It provides some advantages and few limitations compared to a normally-equipped neurosurgical operating theater; our experience shows that the technological advances of this complex operating room are useful though not essential in aneurysm surgery.
引言:BrainSuite(®)是一个高度集成的手术室,主要用于脑肿瘤手术。迄今为止,关于其在血管神经外科常规使用的相关问题尚未在文献中进行讨论。我们报告了在BrainSuite(®)中进行脑动脉瘤手术治疗的经验,旨在评估其安全性、可行性、优缺点及禁忌证。 材料与方法:我们回顾性分析了2007年1月至2013年5月期间所有因破裂和未破裂动脉瘤接受开颅夹闭手术且随后至少随访12个月的患者。术中均进行弥散加权成像(DWI)、磁共振血管造影(MRA)和容积磁共振成像(MRI),以评估血管通畅情况和早期缺血性病变。还从时间的增减以及其作为手术辅助手段对小的远端动脉瘤定位和夹闭策略术前规划的有效性方面评估了导航的作用。 结果:本报告共纳入105例患者。其中,39例为破裂动脉瘤患者,66例为未破裂动脉瘤患者。平均年龄为56.1岁,男女比例为1:2.9。动脉瘤累及的部位及发生率依次为大脑中动脉(MCA)40例(38.1%)、前交通动脉(ACoA)23例(22%)、颈内动脉(ICA)分叉处15例(14.3%)、后交通动脉(PComA)7例(6.6%)、A2段7例(6.6%)、A1 - A2段7例(6.6%)和ICA的C6段6例(5.8%)。所有病例中动脉瘤均成功夹闭并完全排除在血液循环之外,尽管BrainSuite(®)有特殊的头架,但在患者头部定位和固定方面未遇到困难。在颈部暴露颈动脉的情况下,MRI未产生干扰或问题,然而由于手术区域靠近磁体,无法采集下肢大隐静脉。由于血管造影与BrainSuite不兼容,术中从未进行血管造影。术中DWI、MRA和容积MRI被证明是评估夹闭后载瘤血管及其分支通畅情况以及动脉瘤闭塞情况的有效工具。术中微型多普勒超声检查也进行了双重验证。术中DWI还使我们能够评估初始缺血性病变的存在,这些病变可能是直接动脉闭塞和与手术操作相关的早期血管痉挛的后果。对于年轻外科医生而言,在规划夹闭策略特别是在大型复杂动脉瘤(瘤囊累及分支)以及影响远端大脑前动脉和大脑中动脉的小动脉瘤病例中定位动脉瘤时,使用三维模型重建进行脑动脉瘤术中导航可能会有一定帮助。根据格拉斯哥预后评分(GOS)评估的患者预后与术前Hunt和Hess(HH)分级显著相关。特别是HH评分高(IV级和V级)的患者,不良预后(GOS = 1或2)的发生率最高。 结论:BrainSuite(®)手术室完全适合脑动脉瘤手术,但仅适用于可能需要联合血管内治疗的病例。与配备常规设备的神经外科手术室相比,它具有一些优点且局限性较少;我们的经验表明,这个复杂手术室的技术进步在动脉瘤手术中虽有用但并非必不可少。
Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 2015-6
Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 2009-10
Zentralbl Neurochir. 2007-2
Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 2013-8